Strong-Cyclic Planning when Fairness is Not a Valid Assumption. Camacho, A. & McIlraith, S. A. In Workshop on Knowledge-based techniques for problem solving and reasoning (KnowProS'16), 2016. abstract bibtex 2 downloads We address the class of fully-observable non-deterministic (FOND) planning problems where non-deterministic actions are not guaranteed to display fair behavior. Typical solutions to FOND planning either guarantee goal reachability with a bounded number of transitions (so-called strong acyclic solutions), or are predicated on a fairness assumption that presumes each action effect occurs infinitely often when the action is applied infinite times in the same state (so-called strong-cyclic solutions). We introduce the FOND+ planning model, that extends the FOND model with a more informed description of the action transitions. Solutions to FOND+ problems are able to guarantee goal reachability when the classical fairness assumption is not valid. We characterize different topologies, or classes, of solutions showing that typical strong acyclic, fair strong-cyclic planning are particular cases. Finally, we present algorithms to solve each class of problems, and prove empirically that FOND+ solutions are different than strong-cyclic solutions that presume fairness.
@inproceedings{cam-mci-fondplus-knowpros16,
title = {Strong-Cyclic Planning when Fairness is Not a Valid Assumption},
author = {Alberto Camacho and Sheila A. McIlraith},
booktitle = {Workshop on Knowledge-based techniques for problem solving and reasoning ({KnowProS}'16)},
year = {2016},
abstract={We address the class of fully-observable non-deterministic (FOND) planning problems where non-deterministic actions are not guaranteed to display fair behavior. Typical solutions to FOND planning either guarantee goal reachability with a bounded number of transitions (so-called strong acyclic solutions), or are predicated on a fairness assumption that presumes each action effect occurs infinitely often when the action is applied infinite times in the same state (so-called strong-cyclic solutions). We introduce the FOND+ planning model, that extends the FOND model with a more informed description of the action transitions. Solutions to FOND+ problems are able to guarantee goal reachability when the classical fairness assumption is not valid. We characterize different topologies, or classes, of solutions showing that typical strong acyclic, fair strong-cyclic planning are particular cases. Finally, we present algorithms to solve each class of problems, and prove empirically that FOND+ solutions are different than strong-cyclic solutions that presume fairness.}
}
Downloads: 2
{"_id":"ndqDmjSpGEds26NT8","bibbaseid":"camacho-mcilraith-strongcyclicplanningwhenfairnessisnotavalidassumption-2016","downloads":2,"creationDate":"2016-07-07T20:35:36.453Z","title":"Strong-Cyclic Planning when Fairness is Not a Valid Assumption","author_short":["Camacho, A.","McIlraith, S. A."],"year":2016,"bibtype":"inproceedings","biburl":"https://www.cs.toronto.edu/~sheila/publications/list.bib","bibdata":{"bibtype":"inproceedings","type":"inproceedings","title":"Strong-Cyclic Planning when Fairness is Not a Valid Assumption","author":[{"firstnames":["Alberto"],"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Camacho"],"suffixes":[]},{"firstnames":["Sheila","A."],"propositions":[],"lastnames":["McIlraith"],"suffixes":[]}],"booktitle":"Workshop on Knowledge-based techniques for problem solving and reasoning (KnowProS'16)","year":"2016","abstract":"We address the class of fully-observable non-deterministic (FOND) planning problems where non-deterministic actions are not guaranteed to display fair behavior. Typical solutions to FOND planning either guarantee goal reachability with a bounded number of transitions (so-called strong acyclic solutions), or are predicated on a fairness assumption that presumes each action effect occurs infinitely often when the action is applied infinite times in the same state (so-called strong-cyclic solutions). We introduce the FOND+ planning model, that extends the FOND model with a more informed description of the action transitions. Solutions to FOND+ problems are able to guarantee goal reachability when the classical fairness assumption is not valid. We characterize different topologies, or classes, of solutions showing that typical strong acyclic, fair strong-cyclic planning are particular cases. Finally, we present algorithms to solve each class of problems, and prove empirically that FOND+ solutions are different than strong-cyclic solutions that presume fairness.","bibtex":"@inproceedings{cam-mci-fondplus-knowpros16,\n title = {Strong-Cyclic Planning when Fairness is Not a Valid Assumption},\n author = {Alberto Camacho and Sheila A. McIlraith},\n booktitle = {Workshop on Knowledge-based techniques for problem solving and reasoning ({KnowProS}'16)},\n year = {2016},\n abstract={We address the class of fully-observable non-deterministic (FOND) planning problems where non-deterministic actions are not guaranteed to display fair behavior. Typical solutions to FOND planning either guarantee goal reachability with a bounded number of transitions (so-called strong acyclic solutions), or are predicated on a fairness assumption that presumes each action effect occurs infinitely often when the action is applied infinite times in the same state (so-called strong-cyclic solutions). We introduce the FOND+ planning model, that extends the FOND model with a more informed description of the action transitions. Solutions to FOND+ problems are able to guarantee goal reachability when the classical fairness assumption is not valid. We characterize different topologies, or classes, of solutions showing that typical strong acyclic, fair strong-cyclic planning are particular cases. Finally, we present algorithms to solve each class of problems, and prove empirically that FOND+ solutions are different than strong-cyclic solutions that presume fairness.}\n}\n\n\n","author_short":["Camacho, A.","McIlraith, S. A."],"key":"cam-mci-fondplus-knowpros16","id":"cam-mci-fondplus-knowpros16","bibbaseid":"camacho-mcilraith-strongcyclicplanningwhenfairnessisnotavalidassumption-2016","role":"author","urls":{},"metadata":{"authorlinks":{"camacho, a":"http://www.albertocamacho.com/","mcilraith, s":"https://www.cs.toronto.edu/~sheila/preferences/"}},"downloads":2},"search_terms":["strong","cyclic","planning","fairness","valid","assumption","camacho","mcilraith"],"keywords":[],"authorIDs":["2JP7Eg9bhybNpzYiR","3XTrQJhM6WgBbiDbs","3b3gnNFqBHiteKXs2","3wSJLXJ9XuZ2mDm2H","49zg6n33JhWCCjH4G","4zKMDaLdYLdgGQChe","5456dccd8b01c81930000008","59f3b72dee99a95d4d00003b","5Eidhk5inwxxe7JGk","5de9e8f29f521ddf010000f4","5dea039cfac96fde010000ad","5dea0c58fac96fde01000141","5df2ea54b91ab0de010000ea","5df993a1c4ada8de01000019","5df99645c4ada8de0100003b","5dfb881fc2820bdf010001a1","5e046c906ef264df010000b9","5e0b2662fc92e9de01000023","5e10276e2ef76bdf0100009f","5e129793551229df010000b6","5e160321efa1cddf01000277","5e162befdf1bb4de01000116","5e1e7705ce9ed9de0100012a","5e25b773b57878de010001e1","5e26328524c8a6de0100006d","5e2723abf51e02de010001fb","5e272ebd557b88de010000b6","5e2784f755fc50df01000004","5e28be096acacbdf010000d4","5e2b334a27ed83df01000123","5e2e2abccc9e90e4010000fc","5e324da4e45eb5df010000d5","5e326f1a5633c9de010000b0","5e3449e70c807ede01000132","5e3555a950cde4de0100000c","5e37c25d56571fde0100003d","5e380024918d4ede01000092","5e386d181f8af9e00100009b","5e390326dc5b8ade010000ac","5e3c31bf34cd37de01000126","5e40b576019547df010000c0","5e42164870cecede01000048","5e4cec0e3e28aede0100012b","5e4d64b108a8e5de01000031","5e4f53598a3535f3010000cd","5e50202c933046de01000185","5e514743fe5af9df01000091","5e55431aca58a8df0100019a","5e55af2b7d0846de010000c4","5e5a1adc3557f5df010000c2","5e5a5d62b034a8df0100001b","5e5c3af568f281de01000023","5e5c3b1e68f281de01000026","5e5e62255f9e7bee010001bb","5e5e9d8bc0a53dde01000251","5e5ee78ccc2eefde01000085","5e601cf3c064fcde010001dd","5e65c1b1d92058de010000e3","5e665cdd46e828de0100014d","5rfKneErnpvH8A9jA","6RJeJwCaTdt9z5nYv","6vPX7dp4BL2qMjx2i","7bxyKKMGnHxEQh3cj","7deQZsScCfPeKMrqy","9jPSyMaccQATNQzFR","ATNoaRSndJwiMQonw","AtaDzKGXz9bfKWfab","BiCJ3yKjnhWp5CCMC","BsZbZovaHNF4dA3SG","CBLksFoEERH5GZA5T","CEHomL2HupdANcjHm","CzTmxSkSkem3essqH","DPH6F3udnr4WBuFRg","FfGeNRF9QvLSRujvc","GKYqrPg3uj7nu7nbt","GvvCbq8Y4n9QqTySC","H5crAWCHh6CtutSp3","HF25KvZDEBf5Nvp8x","HTN44dpu77wAWF8HE","HhKYdEPpCZAmKPPQc","J5FZeQWmDd6p96K8P","JDoXnkWb7QmkjpPqn","JGfakYisbgxjaayRF","KwLm5LfL8LpgKk8XJ","Lk4oC9xJyhagKJyo6","LwbwhDPiGy5gvQipm","NJYBJe35TWp5FARRc","Ni37kLLmf4zgkdNFZ","RStoeQpfqvDsMSLzJ","S6JseZ2prMTKs24ym","SPGedFjeWXsYiB6tq","T9PWjMkNwX9WQ5frZ","TuqvMAPdZhcxfZKp7","WKpwMkNYj2iNsJ48r","Wipe7PE2hMCo9rb5r","WqZpp9fP47artme8L","XCnXFqMPKPFkRq2kj","XELkWriNsABzHMyaw","XEMAfXz5wSaaLnBkk","YYzBhJWRGjiEKRDnZ","ZgeG2ZjGwAuPqqEmA","aXBRouHw2x2TwqbuE","ah2FNqZqgqkMf7rno","aijWPoggdP77wxPuf","dBkxSxaYwPmKXxEg8","dSvyDxvHdpJ3uQRZS","dXrbumWfb7fR9Kak8","fZgBEq2CFLY5oCbhJ","goc5YRXzjuZMrzKik","hnF3mFjXA6XYLLhgh","htrNC4rPDzh6zfTLS","iEMJPovEGF7jk6vBD","iWkYLX2HSxaiwbphr","j9wxxJ9nPog3bHXaY","jArTXYwhaXss62KJk","jDsmsaB2wJpvPgxE4","jQ6CLx98WT9tg54oT","kHSR5D3QYy2f3iKFf","kSfpomb2i9SWgtiBN","kx2M4GyrQDBEqRT4q","m6X7Yg32T74Fxxn2d","mDT7qYTqNpZo4tXcj","mZRqmrrWcFXhvyhAi","n5nsNDT3PrjBRrmw6","nvsBeFCxyzjQRGPSi","pRtcYGMaZMG8GTaSz","paM4BdJgmXhvmhNf8","t7Mi3Geoz9C8Aibas","tRLzqBJWc3TYzBYox","tmHrh8yBFTwMrLukn","uxproQToHm4wEZeph","vCzpvySfmJ5w7kMBh","vReYR7kzq7n4RR9Ng","wGWyTtcLspnfJaLeT","x6aX8g9rWCY5wzyW2","xW8eSNRWi7bXhQuHC","xZ6wRPENk64YNgMr7","xm2sosMHyKsPj85Pb","yQ8buY4mGRZGmLKte","ybLsHWfLgzQZAQ5WE","zsNPuARLzosfgmFwd"],"dataSources":["FAyKHaeKDYM4aGJk2","euD7cPywCk5gX9zDY","hqqbBi3M3BaCY6ivH","optQ3PYGE2PxhriFJ","2LLKDfkxMDdABm58M","T3oedZczBnZ2Y6GvJ","uKBTF27RvvtN9Ryxw","Jwuh2BtHasSBPk4uf"]}