Defending community? Indigeneity, selfdetermination and institutional ambivalence in the restoration of Lake Whakaki. COOMBES, B. Geoforum, 38(1):60–72, 2007. ![Defending community? Indigeneity, selfdetermination and institutional ambivalence in the restoration of Lake Whakaki [link]](https://bibbase.org/img/filetypes/link.svg "link")
Paper doi abstract bibtex Conservation practitioners have scrutinized the credibility and eVectiveness of community-based natural resource management, noting its romantic misconceptions about communities and their capacities. Early approaches failed to acknowledge the heterogeneity of collective agents, the synergy between decentralization and neoliberalism, or the need to aYrm rural peoples’ entitlements to resources. A Maori community’s attempt to restore Lake Whakaki on New Zealand’s east coast conWrms many of these critiques. The restoration confronts institutional ambivalence, obstructive forces from beyond the zone of Maori inXuence and non-correspondence between community and catchment dynamics. FulWlment of the project requires exogenous resources and authority, but state conservation agencies are ambivalent towards local demands for self-determined development. Nonetheless, an uncommon degree of agency which is grounded within community aspirations for sovereignty suggests that the motivational characteristics of community retain their importance in debates about integrated conservation and development.
@article{coombes_defending_2007,
series = {Oceania / {Pacific}},
title = {Defending community? {Indigeneity}, selfdetermination and institutional ambivalence in the restoration of {Lake} {Whakaki}},
volume = {38},
issn = {00167185},
shorttitle = {Defending community?},
url = {https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0016718506000637},
doi = {10.1016/j.geoforum.2006.05.006},
abstract = {Conservation practitioners have scrutinized the credibility and eVectiveness of community-based natural resource management, noting its romantic misconceptions about communities and their capacities. Early approaches failed to acknowledge the heterogeneity of collective agents, the synergy between decentralization and neoliberalism, or the need to aYrm rural peoples’ entitlements to resources. A Maori community’s attempt to restore Lake Whakaki on New Zealand’s east coast conWrms many of these critiques. The restoration confronts institutional ambivalence, obstructive forces from beyond the zone of Maori inXuence and non-correspondence between community and catchment dynamics. FulWlment of the project requires exogenous resources and authority, but state conservation agencies are ambivalent towards local demands for self-determined development. Nonetheless, an uncommon degree of agency which is grounded within community aspirations for sovereignty suggests that the motivational characteristics of community retain their importance in debates about integrated conservation and development.},
language = {en},
number = {1},
urldate = {2024-03-10},
journal = {Geoforum},
author = {COOMBES, Brad},
year = {2007},
keywords = {Region: Oceania / Pacific, Language: English, Country: New Zealand},
pages = {60--72},
file = {Coombes - 2007 - Defending community Indigeneity, self-determinati.pdf:/Users/bastien/Zotero/storage/S274QRTN/Coombes - 2007 - Defending community Indigeneity, self-determinati.pdf:application/pdf},
}
Downloads: 0
{"_id":"2T9XuwvY2GBhDnRNe","bibbaseid":"coombes-defendingcommunityindigeneityselfdeterminationandinstitutionalambivalenceintherestorationoflakewhakaki-2007","author_short":["COOMBES, B."],"bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","series":"Oceania / Pacific","title":"Defending community? Indigeneity, selfdetermination and institutional ambivalence in the restoration of Lake Whakaki","volume":"38","issn":"00167185","shorttitle":"Defending community?","url":"https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0016718506000637","doi":"10.1016/j.geoforum.2006.05.006","abstract":"Conservation practitioners have scrutinized the credibility and eVectiveness of community-based natural resource management, noting its romantic misconceptions about communities and their capacities. Early approaches failed to acknowledge the heterogeneity of collective agents, the synergy between decentralization and neoliberalism, or the need to aYrm rural peoples’ entitlements to resources. A Maori community’s attempt to restore Lake Whakaki on New Zealand’s east coast conWrms many of these critiques. The restoration confronts institutional ambivalence, obstructive forces from beyond the zone of Maori inXuence and non-correspondence between community and catchment dynamics. FulWlment of the project requires exogenous resources and authority, but state conservation agencies are ambivalent towards local demands for self-determined development. Nonetheless, an uncommon degree of agency which is grounded within community aspirations for sovereignty suggests that the motivational characteristics of community retain their importance in debates about integrated conservation and development.","language":"en","number":"1","urldate":"2024-03-10","journal":"Geoforum","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["COOMBES"],"firstnames":["Brad"],"suffixes":[]}],"year":"2007","keywords":"Region: Oceania / Pacific, Language: English, Country: New Zealand","pages":"60–72","file":"Coombes - 2007 - Defending community Indigeneity, self-determinati.pdf:/Users/bastien/Zotero/storage/S274QRTN/Coombes - 2007 - Defending community Indigeneity, self-determinati.pdf:application/pdf","bibtex":"@article{coombes_defending_2007,\n\tseries = {Oceania / {Pacific}},\n\ttitle = {Defending community? {Indigeneity}, selfdetermination and institutional ambivalence in the restoration of {Lake} {Whakaki}},\n\tvolume = {38},\n\tissn = {00167185},\n\tshorttitle = {Defending community?},\n\turl = {https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0016718506000637},\n\tdoi = {10.1016/j.geoforum.2006.05.006},\n\tabstract = {Conservation practitioners have scrutinized the credibility and eVectiveness of community-based natural resource management, noting its romantic misconceptions about communities and their capacities. Early approaches failed to acknowledge the heterogeneity of collective agents, the synergy between decentralization and neoliberalism, or the need to aYrm rural peoples’ entitlements to resources. A Maori community’s attempt to restore Lake Whakaki on New Zealand’s east coast conWrms many of these critiques. The restoration confronts institutional ambivalence, obstructive forces from beyond the zone of Maori inXuence and non-correspondence between community and catchment dynamics. FulWlment of the project requires exogenous resources and authority, but state conservation agencies are ambivalent towards local demands for self-determined development. Nonetheless, an uncommon degree of agency which is grounded within community aspirations for sovereignty suggests that the motivational characteristics of community retain their importance in debates about integrated conservation and development.},\n\tlanguage = {en},\n\tnumber = {1},\n\turldate = {2024-03-10},\n\tjournal = {Geoforum},\n\tauthor = {COOMBES, Brad},\n\tyear = {2007},\n\tkeywords = {Region: Oceania / Pacific, Language: English, Country: New Zealand},\n\tpages = {60--72},\n\tfile = {Coombes - 2007 - Defending community Indigeneity, self-determinati.pdf:/Users/bastien/Zotero/storage/S274QRTN/Coombes - 2007 - Defending community Indigeneity, self-determinati.pdf:application/pdf},\n}\n\n","author_short":["COOMBES, B."],"key":"coombes_defending_2007","id":"coombes_defending_2007","bibbaseid":"coombes-defendingcommunityindigeneityselfdeterminationandinstitutionalambivalenceintherestorationoflakewhakaki-2007","role":"author","urls":{"Paper":"https://linkinghub.elsevier.com/retrieve/pii/S0016718506000637"},"keyword":["Region: Oceania / Pacific","Language: English","Country: New Zealand"],"metadata":{"authorlinks":{}}},"bibtype":"article","biburl":"http://indigeo.univ-lille.fr/fileadmin/user_upload/indigeo/Base_de_donnees/INDIGEO_2025-03-02.bib","dataSources":["QjBkiYHSyyr5MFHXg","fQ4qTxCp8gnsvSNnz","dYhZW3iG6MeNi7qdJ","3dcFnBwiehtfKhK2D","AERQpuGRNdNBcg27G","A3cMPMNCjGLkNbLs2","9bYJT3wcDaado8heG","FqJS5kPqcFWLJ6Pxc","Dq4CQCKRwJbhxedzc","aN2adD4PvZWLvedQz","uTWqAd4t3GKoBr39Z","uzAmdEfF9r6iCbpGf","5KHmLkdxgphqiG6yw"],"keywords":["region: oceania / pacific","language: english","country: new zealand"],"search_terms":["defending","community","indigeneity","selfdetermination","institutional","ambivalence","restoration","lake","whakaki","coombes"],"title":"Defending community? Indigeneity, selfdetermination and institutional ambivalence in the restoration of Lake Whakaki","year":2007}