Reply to Harwood et al.: Thermophilization Estimation Is Robust to the Scale of Species Distribution Data

Reply to Harwood et al.: Thermophilization Estimation Is Robust to the Scale of Species Distribution Data. De Frenne, P., Rodŕıguez-Sánchez, F., Bernhardt-Römermann, M., Brown, C. D., Eriksson, O., Hermy, M., Mitchell, F. J. G., Petř́ık, P., Van Calster, H., Vellend, M., & Verheyen, K. 111(13):E1166.

Paper doi abstract bibtex

We recently assessed plant community responses to macroclimate warming across European and North American temperate forests (1). To do so, we inferred the temperature preferences of understory species from distribution data by means of ecological niche, or species distribution models (SDMs). Harwood et al. (2) propose that subcanopy temperatures, instead of gridded climate data, should have been used in our analyses. Despite exciting ongoing advances in the downscaling of microclimates from macroclimatic data, Harwood et al.'s suggestion is, at present, simply not possible at the scale of our study

@article{defrenneReplyHarwoodThermophilization2014,
  title = {Reply to {{Harwood}} et al.: {{Thermophilization}} Estimation Is Robust to the Scale of Species Distribution Data},
  author = {De Frenne, Pieter and Rodŕıguez-Sánchez, Francisco and Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus and Brown, Carissa D. and Eriksson, Ove and Hermy, Martin and Mitchell, Fraser J. G. and Petř́ık, Petr and Van Calster, Hans and Vellend, Mark and Verheyen, Kris},
  date = {2014-04},
  journaltitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  volume = {111},
  pages = {E1166},
  issn = {1091-6490},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1401414111},
  url = {https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1401414111},
  abstract = {We recently assessed plant community responses to macroclimate warming across European and North American temperate forests (1). To do so, we inferred the temperature preferences of understory species from distribution data by means of ecological niche, or species distribution models (SDMs). Harwood et al. (2) propose that subcanopy temperatures, instead of gridded climate data, should have been used in our analyses. Despite exciting ongoing advances in the downscaling of microclimates from macroclimatic data, Harwood et al.'s suggestion is, at present, simply not possible at the scale of our study},
  keywords = {*imported-from-citeulike-INRMM,~INRMM-MiD:c-13123322,climate,climate-change,complexity,downscaling,forest-resources,microclimate,niche-modelling,uncertainty,vegetation},
  number = {13}
}

Downloads: 0

{"_id":"dmCpzNTAuuFZT5rkt","bibbaseid":"defrenne-rodguezsnchez-bernhardtrmermann-brown-eriksson-hermy-mitchell-petk-etal-replytoharwoodetalthermophilizationestimationisrobusttothescaleofspeciesdistributiondata","authorIDs":[],"author_short":["De Frenne, P.","Rodŕıguez-Sánchez, F.","Bernhardt-Römermann, M.","Brown, C. D.","Eriksson, O.","Hermy, M.","Mitchell, F. J. G.","Petř́ık, P.","Van Calster, H.","Vellend, M.","Verheyen, K."],"bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","title":"Reply to Harwood et al.: Thermophilization Estimation Is Robust to the Scale of Species Distribution Data","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["De","Frenne"],"firstnames":["Pieter"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Rodŕıguez-Sánchez"],"firstnames":["Francisco"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Bernhardt-Römermann"],"firstnames":["Markus"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Brown"],"firstnames":["Carissa","D."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Eriksson"],"firstnames":["Ove"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Hermy"],"firstnames":["Martin"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Mitchell"],"firstnames":["Fraser","J.","G."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Petř́ık"],"firstnames":["Petr"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Van","Calster"],"firstnames":["Hans"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Vellend"],"firstnames":["Mark"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Verheyen"],"firstnames":["Kris"],"suffixes":[]}],"date":"2014-04","journaltitle":"Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences","volume":"111","pages":"E1166","issn":"1091-6490","doi":"10.1073/pnas.1401414111","url":"https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1401414111","abstract":"We recently assessed plant community responses to macroclimate warming across European and North American temperate forests (1). To do so, we inferred the temperature preferences of understory species from distribution data by means of ecological niche, or species distribution models (SDMs). Harwood et al. (2) propose that subcanopy temperatures, instead of gridded climate data, should have been used in our analyses. Despite exciting ongoing advances in the downscaling of microclimates from macroclimatic data, Harwood et al.'s suggestion is, at present, simply not possible at the scale of our study","keywords":"*imported-from-citeulike-INRMM,~INRMM-MiD:c-13123322,climate,climate-change,complexity,downscaling,forest-resources,microclimate,niche-modelling,uncertainty,vegetation","number":"13","bibtex":"@article{defrenneReplyHarwoodThermophilization2014,\n title = {Reply to {{Harwood}} et al.: {{Thermophilization}} Estimation Is Robust to the Scale of Species Distribution Data},\n author = {De Frenne, Pieter and Rodŕıguez-Sánchez, Francisco and Bernhardt-Römermann, Markus and Brown, Carissa D. and Eriksson, Ove and Hermy, Martin and Mitchell, Fraser J. G. and Petř́ık, Petr and Van Calster, Hans and Vellend, Mark and Verheyen, Kris},\n date = {2014-04},\n journaltitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},\n volume = {111},\n pages = {E1166},\n issn = {1091-6490},\n doi = {10.1073/pnas.1401414111},\n url = {https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1401414111},\n abstract = {We recently assessed plant community responses to macroclimate warming across European and North American temperate forests (1). To do so, we inferred the temperature preferences of understory species from distribution data by means of ecological niche, or species distribution models (SDMs). Harwood et al. (2) propose that subcanopy temperatures, instead of gridded climate data, should have been used in our analyses. Despite exciting ongoing advances in the downscaling of microclimates from macroclimatic data, Harwood et al.'s suggestion is, at present, simply not possible at the scale of our study},\n keywords = {*imported-from-citeulike-INRMM,~INRMM-MiD:c-13123322,climate,climate-change,complexity,downscaling,forest-resources,microclimate,niche-modelling,uncertainty,vegetation},\n number = {13}\n}\n\n","author_short":["De Frenne, P.","Rodŕıguez-Sánchez, F.","Bernhardt-Römermann, M.","Brown, C. D.","Eriksson, O.","Hermy, M.","Mitchell, F. J. G.","Petř́ık, P.","Van Calster, H.","Vellend, M.","Verheyen, K."],"key":"defrenneReplyHarwoodThermophilization2014","id":"defrenneReplyHarwoodThermophilization2014","bibbaseid":"defrenne-rodguezsnchez-bernhardtrmermann-brown-eriksson-hermy-mitchell-petk-etal-replytoharwoodetalthermophilizationestimationisrobusttothescaleofspeciesdistributiondata","role":"author","urls":{"Paper":"https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1401414111"},"keyword":["*imported-from-citeulike-INRMM","~INRMM-MiD:c-13123322","climate","climate-change","complexity","downscaling","forest-resources","microclimate","niche-modelling","uncertainty","vegetation"],"downloads":0},"bibtype":"article","biburl":"https://tmpfiles.org/dl/58794/INRMM.bib","creationDate":"2020-07-02T22:41:04.994Z","downloads":0,"keywords":["*imported-from-citeulike-inrmm","~inrmm-mid:c-13123322","climate","climate-change","complexity","downscaling","forest-resources","microclimate","niche-modelling","uncertainty","vegetation"],"search_terms":["reply","harwood","thermophilization","estimation","robust","scale","species","distribution","data","de frenne","rodŕıguez-sánchez","bernhardt-römermann","brown","eriksson","hermy","mitchell","petř́ık","van calster","vellend","verheyen"],"title":"Reply to Harwood et al.: Thermophilization Estimation Is Robust to the Scale of Species Distribution Data","year":null,"dataSources":["DXuKbcZTirdigFKPF"]}