Implementations are not conceptualizations: Revising the verb learning model. MacWhinney, B & Leinbach, J Cognition, 40(1-2):121-57, 1991. abstract bibtex In a recent issue of this journal, Pinker and Prince (1988) and Lachter and Bever (1988) presented detailed critiques of Rumelhart and McClelland's (1986) connectionist model of the child's learning of the phonological form of the English past tense. In order to address these criticisms, a new connectionist model was constructed using the back-propagation algorithm, a larger input corpus, a fuller paradigm, and a new phonological representation. This new implementation successfully addressed the criticisms of the phonological representation used by Rumelhart and McClelland. It did a much better job of learning the past tense using a fuller input set with realistic frequencies of occurrence. Ancillary simulations using the same network were able to deal with the homonymy problem and the generation of forms like "ated" from "ate". The one feature not provided by the new model was a way of modeling early correct production of irregular forms. The success of the new model can be used to help clarify the extent to which the published critiques apply to a particular connectionist implementation as opposed to fundamental principles underlying the broader connectionist conceptualization.
@Article{MacWhinney1991,
author = {B MacWhinney and J Leinbach},
journal = {Cognition},
title = {Implementations are not conceptualizations: {R}evising the verb learning model.},
year = {1991},
number = {1-2},
pages = {121-57},
volume = {40},
abstract = {In a recent issue of this journal, Pinker and Prince (1988) and Lachter
and Bever (1988) presented detailed critiques of Rumelhart and McClelland's
(1986) connectionist model of the child's learning of the phonological
form of the English past tense. In order to address these criticisms,
a new connectionist model was constructed using the back-propagation
algorithm, a larger input corpus, a fuller paradigm, and a new phonological
representation. This new implementation successfully addressed the
criticisms of the phonological representation used by Rumelhart and
McClelland. It did a much better job of learning the past tense using
a fuller input set with realistic frequencies of occurrence. Ancillary
simulations using the same network were able to deal with the homonymy
problem and the generation of forms like "ated" from "ate". The one
feature not provided by the new model was a way of modeling early
correct production of irregular forms. The success of the new model
can be used to help clarify the extent to which the published critiques
apply to a particular connectionist implementation as opposed to
fundamental principles underlying the broader connectionist conceptualization.},
keywords = {Computing Methodologies, Human, Language, Learning, Mental Processes, Models, Theoretical, Stochastic Processes, Support, U.S. Gov't, Non-P.H.S., Cognition, Linguistics, Neural Networks (Computer), Practice (Psychology), Non-U.S. Gov't, Memory, Psychological, Task Performance and Analysis, Time Factors, Visual Perception, Adult, Attention, Discrimination Learning, Female, Male, Short-Term, Mental Recall, Orientation, Pattern Recognition, Visual, Perceptual Masking, Reading, Concept Formation, Form Perception, Animals, Corpus Striatum, Shrews, P.H.S., Visual Cortex, Visual Pathways, Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Cortex, Auditory Perception, Cochlea, Ear, Gerbillinae, Glycine, Hearing, Neurons, Space Perception, Strychnine, Adolescent, Decision Making, Reaction Time, Astrocytoma, Brain Mapping, Brain Neoplasms, Cerebral Cortex, Electric Stimulation, Electrophysiology, Epilepsy, Temporal Lobe, Evoked Potentials, Frontal Lobe, Noise, Parietal Lobe, Scalp, Child, Language Development, Psycholinguistics, Brain, Perception, Speech, Vocalization, Animal, Discrimination (Psychology), Hippocampus, Rats, Calcium, Chelating Agents, Excitatory Postsynaptic Potentials, Glutamic Acid, Guanosine Diphosphate, In Vitro, Neuronal Plasticity, Pyramidal Cells, Receptors, AMPA, Metabotropic Glutamate, N-Methyl-D-Aspartate, Somatosensory Cortex, Synapses, Synaptic Transmission, Thionucleotides, Action Potentials, Calcium Channels, L-Type, Electric Conductivity, Entorhinal Cortex, Neurological, Long-Evans, Infant, Mathematics, Statistics, Probability Learning, Problem Solving, Psychophysics, Association Learning, Child Psychology, Habituation (Psychophysiology), Probability Theory, Analysis of Variance, Semantics, Symbolism, Behavior, Eye Movements, Macaca mulatta, Prefrontal Cortex, Cats, Dogs, Haplorhini, Photic Stimulation, Electroencephalography, Nervous System Physiology, Darkness, Grasshoppers, Light, Membrane Potentials, Neural Inhibition, Afferent, Picrotoxin, Vision, Deoxyglucose, Injections, Microspheres, Neural Pathways, Rhodamines, Choice Behavior, Speech Perception, Verbal Learning, Dominance, Cerebral, Fixation, Ocular, Language Tests, Random Allocation, Comparative Study, Saguinus, Sound Spectrography, Species Specificity, Audiometry, Auditory Threshold, Calibration, Data Interpretation, Statistical, Anesthesia, General, Electrodes, Implanted, Pitch Perception, Sound Localization, Paired-Associate Learning, Serial Learning, Auditory, Age Factors, Motion Perception, Brain Injuries, Computer Simulation, Blindness, Psychomotor Performance, Color Perception, Signal Detection (Psychology), Judgment, ROC Curve, Regression Analysis, Music, Probability, Arm, Cerebrovascular Disorders, Hemiplegia, Movement, Muscle, Skeletal, Myoclonus, Robotics, Magnetoencephalography, Phonetics, Software, Speech Production Measurement, Epilepsies, Partial, Laterality, Stereotaxic Techniques, 1786671},
}
Downloads: 0
{"_id":"DvCnRR7NkKWvPssLj","bibbaseid":"macwhinney-leinbach-implementationsarenotconceptualizationsrevisingtheverblearningmodel-1991","author_short":["MacWhinney, B","Leinbach, J"],"bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","author":[{"firstnames":["B"],"propositions":[],"lastnames":["MacWhinney"],"suffixes":[]},{"firstnames":["J"],"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Leinbach"],"suffixes":[]}],"journal":"Cognition","title":"Implementations are not conceptualizations: Revising the verb learning model.","year":"1991","number":"1-2","pages":"121-57","volume":"40","abstract":"In a recent issue of this journal, Pinker and Prince (1988) and Lachter and Bever (1988) presented detailed critiques of Rumelhart and McClelland's (1986) connectionist model of the child's learning of the phonological form of the English past tense. In order to address these criticisms, a new connectionist model was constructed using the back-propagation algorithm, a larger input corpus, a fuller paradigm, and a new phonological representation. This new implementation successfully addressed the criticisms of the phonological representation used by Rumelhart and McClelland. It did a much better job of learning the past tense using a fuller input set with realistic frequencies of occurrence. Ancillary simulations using the same network were able to deal with the homonymy problem and the generation of forms like \"ated\" from \"ate\". The one feature not provided by the new model was a way of modeling early correct production of irregular forms. The success of the new model can be used to help clarify the extent to which the published critiques apply to a particular connectionist implementation as opposed to fundamental principles underlying the broader connectionist conceptualization.","keywords":"Computing Methodologies, Human, Language, Learning, Mental Processes, Models, Theoretical, Stochastic Processes, Support, U.S. Gov't, Non-P.H.S., Cognition, Linguistics, Neural Networks (Computer), Practice (Psychology), Non-U.S. Gov't, Memory, Psychological, Task Performance and Analysis, Time Factors, Visual Perception, Adult, Attention, Discrimination Learning, Female, Male, Short-Term, Mental Recall, Orientation, Pattern Recognition, Visual, Perceptual Masking, Reading, Concept Formation, Form Perception, Animals, Corpus Striatum, Shrews, P.H.S., Visual Cortex, Visual Pathways, Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Cortex, Auditory Perception, Cochlea, Ear, Gerbillinae, Glycine, Hearing, Neurons, Space Perception, Strychnine, Adolescent, Decision Making, Reaction Time, Astrocytoma, Brain Mapping, Brain Neoplasms, Cerebral Cortex, Electric Stimulation, Electrophysiology, Epilepsy, Temporal Lobe, Evoked Potentials, Frontal Lobe, Noise, Parietal Lobe, Scalp, Child, Language Development, Psycholinguistics, Brain, Perception, Speech, Vocalization, Animal, Discrimination (Psychology), Hippocampus, Rats, Calcium, Chelating Agents, Excitatory Postsynaptic Potentials, Glutamic Acid, Guanosine Diphosphate, In Vitro, Neuronal Plasticity, Pyramidal Cells, Receptors, AMPA, Metabotropic Glutamate, N-Methyl-D-Aspartate, Somatosensory Cortex, Synapses, Synaptic Transmission, Thionucleotides, Action Potentials, Calcium Channels, L-Type, Electric Conductivity, Entorhinal Cortex, Neurological, Long-Evans, Infant, Mathematics, Statistics, Probability Learning, Problem Solving, Psychophysics, Association Learning, Child Psychology, Habituation (Psychophysiology), Probability Theory, Analysis of Variance, Semantics, Symbolism, Behavior, Eye Movements, Macaca mulatta, Prefrontal Cortex, Cats, Dogs, Haplorhini, Photic Stimulation, Electroencephalography, Nervous System Physiology, Darkness, Grasshoppers, Light, Membrane Potentials, Neural Inhibition, Afferent, Picrotoxin, Vision, Deoxyglucose, Injections, Microspheres, Neural Pathways, Rhodamines, Choice Behavior, Speech Perception, Verbal Learning, Dominance, Cerebral, Fixation, Ocular, Language Tests, Random Allocation, Comparative Study, Saguinus, Sound Spectrography, Species Specificity, Audiometry, Auditory Threshold, Calibration, Data Interpretation, Statistical, Anesthesia, General, Electrodes, Implanted, Pitch Perception, Sound Localization, Paired-Associate Learning, Serial Learning, Auditory, Age Factors, Motion Perception, Brain Injuries, Computer Simulation, Blindness, Psychomotor Performance, Color Perception, Signal Detection (Psychology), Judgment, ROC Curve, Regression Analysis, Music, Probability, Arm, Cerebrovascular Disorders, Hemiplegia, Movement, Muscle, Skeletal, Myoclonus, Robotics, Magnetoencephalography, Phonetics, Software, Speech Production Measurement, Epilepsies, Partial, Laterality, Stereotaxic Techniques, 1786671","bibtex":"@Article{MacWhinney1991,\n author = {B MacWhinney and J Leinbach},\n journal = {Cognition},\n title = {Implementations are not conceptualizations: {R}evising the verb learning model.},\n year = {1991},\n number = {1-2},\n pages = {121-57},\n volume = {40},\n abstract = {In a recent issue of this journal, Pinker and Prince (1988) and Lachter\n\tand Bever (1988) presented detailed critiques of Rumelhart and McClelland's\n\t(1986) connectionist model of the child's learning of the phonological\n\tform of the English past tense. In order to address these criticisms,\n\ta new connectionist model was constructed using the back-propagation\n\talgorithm, a larger input corpus, a fuller paradigm, and a new phonological\n\trepresentation. This new implementation successfully addressed the\n\tcriticisms of the phonological representation used by Rumelhart and\n\tMcClelland. It did a much better job of learning the past tense using\n\ta fuller input set with realistic frequencies of occurrence. Ancillary\n\tsimulations using the same network were able to deal with the homonymy\n\tproblem and the generation of forms like \"ated\" from \"ate\". The one\n\tfeature not provided by the new model was a way of modeling early\n\tcorrect production of irregular forms. The success of the new model\n\tcan be used to help clarify the extent to which the published critiques\n\tapply to a particular connectionist implementation as opposed to\n\tfundamental principles underlying the broader connectionist conceptualization.},\n keywords = {Computing Methodologies, Human, Language, Learning, Mental Processes, Models, Theoretical, Stochastic Processes, Support, U.S. Gov't, Non-P.H.S., Cognition, Linguistics, Neural Networks (Computer), Practice (Psychology), Non-U.S. Gov't, Memory, Psychological, Task Performance and Analysis, Time Factors, Visual Perception, Adult, Attention, Discrimination Learning, Female, Male, Short-Term, Mental Recall, Orientation, Pattern Recognition, Visual, Perceptual Masking, Reading, Concept Formation, Form Perception, Animals, Corpus Striatum, Shrews, P.H.S., Visual Cortex, Visual Pathways, Acoustic Stimulation, Auditory Cortex, Auditory Perception, Cochlea, Ear, Gerbillinae, Glycine, Hearing, Neurons, Space Perception, Strychnine, Adolescent, Decision Making, Reaction Time, Astrocytoma, Brain Mapping, Brain Neoplasms, Cerebral Cortex, Electric Stimulation, Electrophysiology, Epilepsy, Temporal Lobe, Evoked Potentials, Frontal Lobe, Noise, Parietal Lobe, Scalp, Child, Language Development, Psycholinguistics, Brain, Perception, Speech, Vocalization, Animal, Discrimination (Psychology), Hippocampus, Rats, Calcium, Chelating Agents, Excitatory Postsynaptic Potentials, Glutamic Acid, Guanosine Diphosphate, In Vitro, Neuronal Plasticity, Pyramidal Cells, Receptors, AMPA, Metabotropic Glutamate, N-Methyl-D-Aspartate, Somatosensory Cortex, Synapses, Synaptic Transmission, Thionucleotides, Action Potentials, Calcium Channels, L-Type, Electric Conductivity, Entorhinal Cortex, Neurological, Long-Evans, Infant, Mathematics, Statistics, Probability Learning, Problem Solving, Psychophysics, Association Learning, Child Psychology, Habituation (Psychophysiology), Probability Theory, Analysis of Variance, Semantics, Symbolism, Behavior, Eye Movements, Macaca mulatta, Prefrontal Cortex, Cats, Dogs, Haplorhini, Photic Stimulation, Electroencephalography, Nervous System Physiology, Darkness, Grasshoppers, Light, Membrane Potentials, Neural Inhibition, Afferent, Picrotoxin, Vision, Deoxyglucose, Injections, Microspheres, Neural Pathways, Rhodamines, Choice Behavior, Speech Perception, Verbal Learning, Dominance, Cerebral, Fixation, Ocular, Language Tests, Random Allocation, Comparative Study, Saguinus, Sound Spectrography, Species Specificity, Audiometry, Auditory Threshold, Calibration, Data Interpretation, Statistical, Anesthesia, General, Electrodes, Implanted, Pitch Perception, Sound Localization, Paired-Associate Learning, Serial Learning, Auditory, Age Factors, Motion Perception, Brain Injuries, Computer Simulation, Blindness, Psychomotor Performance, Color Perception, Signal Detection (Psychology), Judgment, ROC Curve, Regression Analysis, Music, Probability, Arm, Cerebrovascular Disorders, Hemiplegia, Movement, Muscle, Skeletal, Myoclonus, Robotics, Magnetoencephalography, Phonetics, Software, Speech Production Measurement, Epilepsies, Partial, Laterality, Stereotaxic Techniques, 1786671},\n}\n\n","author_short":["MacWhinney, B","Leinbach, J"],"key":"MacWhinney1991","id":"MacWhinney1991","bibbaseid":"macwhinney-leinbach-implementationsarenotconceptualizationsrevisingtheverblearningmodel-1991","role":"author","urls":{},"keyword":["Computing Methodologies","Human","Language","Learning","Mental Processes","Models","Theoretical","Stochastic Processes","Support","U.S. Gov't","Non-P.H.S.","Cognition","Linguistics","Neural Networks (Computer)","Practice (Psychology)","Non-U.S. Gov't","Memory","Psychological","Task Performance and Analysis","Time Factors","Visual Perception","Adult","Attention","Discrimination Learning","Female","Male","Short-Term","Mental Recall","Orientation","Pattern Recognition","Visual","Perceptual Masking","Reading","Concept Formation","Form Perception","Animals","Corpus Striatum","Shrews","P.H.S.","Visual Cortex","Visual Pathways","Acoustic Stimulation","Auditory Cortex","Auditory Perception","Cochlea","Ear","Gerbillinae","Glycine","Hearing","Neurons","Space Perception","Strychnine","Adolescent","Decision Making","Reaction Time","Astrocytoma","Brain Mapping","Brain Neoplasms","Cerebral Cortex","Electric Stimulation","Electrophysiology","Epilepsy","Temporal Lobe","Evoked Potentials","Frontal Lobe","Noise","Parietal Lobe","Scalp","Child","Language Development","Psycholinguistics","Brain","Perception","Speech","Vocalization","Animal","Discrimination (Psychology)","Hippocampus","Rats","Calcium","Chelating Agents","Excitatory Postsynaptic Potentials","Glutamic Acid","Guanosine Diphosphate","In Vitro","Neuronal Plasticity","Pyramidal Cells","Receptors","AMPA","Metabotropic Glutamate","N-Methyl-D-Aspartate","Somatosensory Cortex","Synapses","Synaptic Transmission","Thionucleotides","Action Potentials","Calcium Channels","L-Type","Electric Conductivity","Entorhinal Cortex","Neurological","Long-Evans","Infant","Mathematics","Statistics","Probability Learning","Problem Solving","Psychophysics","Association Learning","Child Psychology","Habituation (Psychophysiology)","Probability Theory","Analysis of Variance","Semantics","Symbolism","Behavior","Eye Movements","Macaca mulatta","Prefrontal Cortex","Cats","Dogs","Haplorhini","Photic Stimulation","Electroencephalography","Nervous System Physiology","Darkness","Grasshoppers","Light","Membrane Potentials","Neural Inhibition","Afferent","Picrotoxin","Vision","Deoxyglucose","Injections","Microspheres","Neural Pathways","Rhodamines","Choice Behavior","Speech Perception","Verbal Learning","Dominance","Cerebral","Fixation","Ocular","Language Tests","Random Allocation","Comparative Study","Saguinus","Sound Spectrography","Species Specificity","Audiometry","Auditory Threshold","Calibration","Data Interpretation","Statistical","Anesthesia","General","Electrodes","Implanted","Pitch Perception","Sound Localization","Paired-Associate Learning","Serial Learning","Auditory","Age Factors","Motion Perception","Brain Injuries","Computer Simulation","Blindness","Psychomotor Performance","Color Perception","Signal Detection (Psychology)","Judgment","ROC Curve","Regression Analysis","Music","Probability","Arm","Cerebrovascular Disorders","Hemiplegia","Movement","Muscle","Skeletal","Myoclonus","Robotics","Magnetoencephalography","Phonetics","Software","Speech Production Measurement","Epilepsies","Partial","Laterality","Stereotaxic Techniques","1786671"],"metadata":{"authorlinks":{}}},"bibtype":"article","biburl":"https://endress.org/publications/ansgar.bib","dataSources":["xPGxHAeh3vZpx4yyE","5qXSH7BrePnXHtcrf","TXa55dQbNoWnaGmMq"],"keywords":["computing methodologies","human","language","learning","mental processes","models","theoretical","stochastic processes","support","u.s. gov't","non-p.h.s.","cognition","linguistics","neural networks (computer)","practice (psychology)","non-u.s. gov't","memory","psychological","task performance and analysis","time factors","visual perception","adult","attention","discrimination learning","female","male","short-term","mental recall","orientation","pattern recognition","visual","perceptual masking","reading","concept formation","form perception","animals","corpus striatum","shrews","p.h.s.","visual cortex","visual pathways","acoustic stimulation","auditory cortex","auditory perception","cochlea","ear","gerbillinae","glycine","hearing","neurons","space perception","strychnine","adolescent","decision making","reaction time","astrocytoma","brain mapping","brain neoplasms","cerebral cortex","electric stimulation","electrophysiology","epilepsy","temporal lobe","evoked potentials","frontal lobe","noise","parietal lobe","scalp","child","language development","psycholinguistics","brain","perception","speech","vocalization","animal","discrimination (psychology)","hippocampus","rats","calcium","chelating agents","excitatory postsynaptic potentials","glutamic acid","guanosine diphosphate","in vitro","neuronal plasticity","pyramidal cells","receptors","ampa","metabotropic glutamate","n-methyl-d-aspartate","somatosensory cortex","synapses","synaptic transmission","thionucleotides","action potentials","calcium channels","l-type","electric conductivity","entorhinal cortex","neurological","long-evans","infant","mathematics","statistics","probability learning","problem solving","psychophysics","association learning","child psychology","habituation (psychophysiology)","probability theory","analysis of variance","semantics","symbolism","behavior","eye movements","macaca mulatta","prefrontal cortex","cats","dogs","haplorhini","photic stimulation","electroencephalography","nervous system physiology","darkness","grasshoppers","light","membrane potentials","neural inhibition","afferent","picrotoxin","vision","deoxyglucose","injections","microspheres","neural pathways","rhodamines","choice behavior","speech perception","verbal learning","dominance","cerebral","fixation","ocular","language tests","random allocation","comparative study","saguinus","sound spectrography","species specificity","audiometry","auditory threshold","calibration","data interpretation","statistical","anesthesia","general","electrodes","implanted","pitch perception","sound localization","paired-associate learning","serial learning","auditory","age factors","motion perception","brain injuries","computer simulation","blindness","psychomotor performance","color perception","signal detection (psychology)","judgment","roc curve","regression analysis","music","probability","arm","cerebrovascular disorders","hemiplegia","movement","muscle","skeletal","myoclonus","robotics","magnetoencephalography","phonetics","software","speech production measurement","epilepsies","partial","laterality","stereotaxic techniques","1786671"],"search_terms":["implementations","conceptualizations","revising","verb","learning","model","macwhinney","leinbach"],"title":"Implementations are not conceptualizations: Revising the verb learning model.","year":1991}