When Political Ignorance is really harmful for Democracy: Moral Intuitions and Biased Attitudes in Voting Behaviour. Marchetti, J. Philosophy & Social Criticism, 49(9):1046–1060, 2023. doi abstract bibtex Ignorance about political related issues has long been considered a threat to democracy. This paper revolves around the concept of political ignorance, focusing especially on Ilya Somin’s book Democracy and Political Ignorance and going beyond his standpoint in two ways. First of all, it moves away from the notion of factual knowledge by showing that political ignorance cannot be limited to a matter of information quality. On the contrary, it shows that ignorance concerns the formation of opinions about political facts, which are the bricks with which disagreement is built. Then, using the insights of the Moral Foundation Theory by Jonathan Haidt and his colleagues, the paper argues that moral intuitions represent an additional source of bias that current research on the problem of voters’ ignorance should address. While Somin argues that biased moral values are the outcome of ignorance, Moral Foundation Theory suggests that moral intuitions are a robust determinant of people’s political views as they make factual knowledge partially irrelevant and also make people with different moral minds unable to understand the basis of reciprocal factual argumentations.
@article{marchetti2023,
title = {When {Political} {Ignorance} is really harmful for {Democracy}: {Moral} {Intuitions} and {Biased} {Attitudes} in {Voting} {Behaviour}},
volume = {49},
issn = {1461-734X},
doi = {10.1177/01914537221093742},
abstract = {Ignorance about political related issues has long been considered a threat to democracy. This paper revolves around the concept of political ignorance, focusing especially on Ilya Somin’s book Democracy and Political Ignorance and going beyond his standpoint in two ways. First of all, it moves away from the notion of factual knowledge by showing that political ignorance cannot be limited to a matter of information quality. On the contrary, it shows that ignorance concerns the formation of opinions about political facts, which are the bricks with which disagreement is built. Then, using the insights of the Moral Foundation Theory by Jonathan Haidt and his colleagues, the paper argues that moral intuitions represent an additional source of bias that current research on the problem of voters’ ignorance should address. While Somin argues that biased moral values are the outcome of ignorance, Moral Foundation Theory suggests that moral intuitions are a robust determinant of people’s political views as they make factual knowledge partially irrelevant and also make people with different moral minds unable to understand the basis of reciprocal factual argumentations.},
number = {9},
journal = {Philosophy \& Social Criticism},
author = {Marchetti, Jacopo},
year = {2023},
keywords = {Somin, democratic disagreement, moral foundation theory, political ignorance},
pages = {1046--1060},
}
Downloads: 0
{"_id":"kAFKbC7tTgbWkhxbC","bibbaseid":"marchetti-whenpoliticalignoranceisreallyharmfulfordemocracymoralintuitionsandbiasedattitudesinvotingbehaviour-2023","author_short":["Marchetti, J."],"bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","title":"When Political Ignorance is really harmful for Democracy: Moral Intuitions and Biased Attitudes in Voting Behaviour","volume":"49","issn":"1461-734X","doi":"10.1177/01914537221093742","abstract":"Ignorance about political related issues has long been considered a threat to democracy. This paper revolves around the concept of political ignorance, focusing especially on Ilya Somin’s book Democracy and Political Ignorance and going beyond his standpoint in two ways. First of all, it moves away from the notion of factual knowledge by showing that political ignorance cannot be limited to a matter of information quality. On the contrary, it shows that ignorance concerns the formation of opinions about political facts, which are the bricks with which disagreement is built. Then, using the insights of the Moral Foundation Theory by Jonathan Haidt and his colleagues, the paper argues that moral intuitions represent an additional source of bias that current research on the problem of voters’ ignorance should address. While Somin argues that biased moral values are the outcome of ignorance, Moral Foundation Theory suggests that moral intuitions are a robust determinant of people’s political views as they make factual knowledge partially irrelevant and also make people with different moral minds unable to understand the basis of reciprocal factual argumentations.","number":"9","journal":"Philosophy & Social Criticism","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Marchetti"],"firstnames":["Jacopo"],"suffixes":[]}],"year":"2023","keywords":"Somin, democratic disagreement, moral foundation theory, political ignorance","pages":"1046–1060","bibtex":"@article{marchetti2023,\n\ttitle = {When {Political} {Ignorance} is really harmful for {Democracy}: {Moral} {Intuitions} and {Biased} {Attitudes} in {Voting} {Behaviour}},\n\tvolume = {49},\n\tissn = {1461-734X},\n\tdoi = {10.1177/01914537221093742},\n\tabstract = {Ignorance about political related issues has long been considered a threat to democracy. This paper revolves around the concept of political ignorance, focusing especially on Ilya Somin’s book Democracy and Political Ignorance and going beyond his standpoint in two ways. First of all, it moves away from the notion of factual knowledge by showing that political ignorance cannot be limited to a matter of information quality. On the contrary, it shows that ignorance concerns the formation of opinions about political facts, which are the bricks with which disagreement is built. Then, using the insights of the Moral Foundation Theory by Jonathan Haidt and his colleagues, the paper argues that moral intuitions represent an additional source of bias that current research on the problem of voters’ ignorance should address. While Somin argues that biased moral values are the outcome of ignorance, Moral Foundation Theory suggests that moral intuitions are a robust determinant of people’s political views as they make factual knowledge partially irrelevant and also make people with different moral minds unable to understand the basis of reciprocal factual argumentations.},\n\tnumber = {9},\n\tjournal = {Philosophy \\& Social Criticism},\n\tauthor = {Marchetti, Jacopo},\n\tyear = {2023},\n\tkeywords = {Somin, democratic disagreement, moral foundation theory, political ignorance},\n\tpages = {1046--1060},\n}\n\n","author_short":["Marchetti, J."],"key":"marchetti2023","id":"marchetti2023","bibbaseid":"marchetti-whenpoliticalignoranceisreallyharmfulfordemocracymoralintuitionsandbiasedattitudesinvotingbehaviour-2023","role":"author","urls":{},"keyword":["Somin","democratic disagreement","moral foundation theory","political ignorance"],"metadata":{"authorlinks":{}}},"bibtype":"article","biburl":"http://bibbase.org/zotero-group/science_et_ignorance/1340424","dataSources":["zX4acseCDM6D58AW7","5XkfmA9xajmKjWGio"],"keywords":["somin","democratic disagreement","moral foundation theory","political ignorance"],"search_terms":["political","ignorance","really","harmful","democracy","moral","intuitions","biased","attitudes","voting","behaviour","marchetti"],"title":"When Political Ignorance is really harmful for Democracy: Moral Intuitions and Biased Attitudes in Voting Behaviour","year":2023}