Historical Fundamentalism? Christian Nationalism and Ignorance About Religion in American Political History. Perry, S. L., Braunstein, R., Gorski, P. S., & Grubbs, J. B. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 61(1):21–40, 2022. doi abstract bibtex Religious right leaders often promulgate views of Christianity's historical preeminence, privilege, and persecution in the United States that are factually incorrect, suggesting credulity, ignorance, or perhaps, a form of ideologically motivated ignorance on the part of their audience. This study examines whether Christian nationalism predicts explicit misconceptions regarding religion in American political history and explores theories about the connection. Analyzing nationally representative panel data containing true/false statements about religion's place in America's founding documents, policies, and court decisions, Christian nationalism is the strongest predictor that Americans fail to affirm factually correct answers. This association is stronger among whites compared to black Americans and religiosity actually predicts selecting factually correct answers once we account for Christian nationalism. Analyses of “do not know” response patterns find more confident correct answers from Americans who reject Christian nationalism and more confident incorrect answers from Americans who embrace Christian nationalism. We theorize that, much like conservative Christians have been shown to incorrectly answer science questions that are “religiously contested,” Christian nationalism inclines Americans to affirm factually incorrect views about religion in American political history, likely through their exposure to certain disseminators of such misinformation, but also through their allegiance to a particular political-cultural narrative they wish to privilege.
@article{perryHistoricalFundamentalismChristian2022,
title = {Historical {{Fundamentalism}}? {{Christian Nationalism}} and {{Ignorance About Religion}} in {{American Political History}}},
shorttitle = {Historical {{Fundamentalism}}?},
author = {Perry, Samuel L. and Braunstein, Ruth and Gorski, Philip S. and Grubbs, Joshua B.},
year = {2022},
journal = {Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion},
volume = {61},
number = {1},
pages = {21--40},
issn = {1468-5906},
doi = {10.1111/jssr.12760},
abstract = {Religious right leaders often promulgate views of Christianity's historical preeminence, privilege, and persecution in the United States that are factually incorrect, suggesting credulity, ignorance, or perhaps, a form of ideologically motivated ignorance on the part of their audience. This study examines whether Christian nationalism predicts explicit misconceptions regarding religion in American political history and explores theories about the connection. Analyzing nationally representative panel data containing true/false statements about religion's place in America's founding documents, policies, and court decisions, Christian nationalism is the strongest predictor that Americans fail to affirm factually correct answers. This association is stronger among whites compared to black Americans and religiosity actually predicts selecting factually correct answers once we account for Christian nationalism. Analyses of “do not know” response patterns find more confident correct answers from Americans who reject Christian nationalism and more confident incorrect answers from Americans who embrace Christian nationalism. We theorize that, much like conservative Christians have been shown to incorrectly answer science questions that are “religiously contested,” Christian nationalism inclines Americans to affirm factually incorrect views about religion in American political history, likely through their exposure to certain disseminators of such misinformation, but also through their allegiance to a particular political-cultural narrative they wish to privilege.},
langid = {english},
keywords = {America,Christian nationalism,history,politics,religion},
annotation = {\_eprint: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/jssr.12760},
file = {/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/5RRV4BMR/Perry et al. - Historical Fundamentalism Christian Nationalism a.pdf;/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/A77RVTT5/jssr.html;/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/X8KKJZTS/jssr.html}
}
Downloads: 0
{"_id":"yv8u7CAPcQ6dyXG23","bibbaseid":"perry-braunstein-gorski-grubbs-historicalfundamentalismchristiannationalismandignoranceaboutreligioninamericanpoliticalhistory-2022","author_short":["Perry, S. L.","Braunstein, R.","Gorski, P. S.","Grubbs, J. B."],"bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","title":"Historical Fundamentalism? Christian Nationalism and Ignorance About Religion in American Political History","shorttitle":"Historical Fundamentalism?","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Perry"],"firstnames":["Samuel","L."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Braunstein"],"firstnames":["Ruth"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Gorski"],"firstnames":["Philip","S."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Grubbs"],"firstnames":["Joshua","B."],"suffixes":[]}],"year":"2022","journal":"Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion","volume":"61","number":"1","pages":"21–40","issn":"1468-5906","doi":"10.1111/jssr.12760","abstract":"Religious right leaders often promulgate views of Christianity's historical preeminence, privilege, and persecution in the United States that are factually incorrect, suggesting credulity, ignorance, or perhaps, a form of ideologically motivated ignorance on the part of their audience. This study examines whether Christian nationalism predicts explicit misconceptions regarding religion in American political history and explores theories about the connection. Analyzing nationally representative panel data containing true/false statements about religion's place in America's founding documents, policies, and court decisions, Christian nationalism is the strongest predictor that Americans fail to affirm factually correct answers. This association is stronger among whites compared to black Americans and religiosity actually predicts selecting factually correct answers once we account for Christian nationalism. Analyses of “do not know” response patterns find more confident correct answers from Americans who reject Christian nationalism and more confident incorrect answers from Americans who embrace Christian nationalism. We theorize that, much like conservative Christians have been shown to incorrectly answer science questions that are “religiously contested,” Christian nationalism inclines Americans to affirm factually incorrect views about religion in American political history, likely through their exposure to certain disseminators of such misinformation, but also through their allegiance to a particular political-cultural narrative they wish to privilege.","langid":"english","keywords":"America,Christian nationalism,history,politics,religion","annotation":"_eprint: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/jssr.12760","file":"/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/5RRV4BMR/Perry et al. - Historical Fundamentalism Christian Nationalism a.pdf;/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/A77RVTT5/jssr.html;/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/X8KKJZTS/jssr.html","bibtex":"@article{perryHistoricalFundamentalismChristian2022,\n title = {Historical {{Fundamentalism}}? {{Christian Nationalism}} and {{Ignorance About Religion}} in {{American Political History}}},\n shorttitle = {Historical {{Fundamentalism}}?},\n author = {Perry, Samuel L. and Braunstein, Ruth and Gorski, Philip S. and Grubbs, Joshua B.},\n year = {2022},\n journal = {Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion},\n volume = {61},\n number = {1},\n pages = {21--40},\n issn = {1468-5906},\n doi = {10.1111/jssr.12760},\n abstract = {Religious right leaders often promulgate views of Christianity's historical preeminence, privilege, and persecution in the United States that are factually incorrect, suggesting credulity, ignorance, or perhaps, a form of ideologically motivated ignorance on the part of their audience. This study examines whether Christian nationalism predicts explicit misconceptions regarding religion in American political history and explores theories about the connection. Analyzing nationally representative panel data containing true/false statements about religion's place in America's founding documents, policies, and court decisions, Christian nationalism is the strongest predictor that Americans fail to affirm factually correct answers. This association is stronger among whites compared to black Americans and religiosity actually predicts selecting factually correct answers once we account for Christian nationalism. Analyses of “do not know” response patterns find more confident correct answers from Americans who reject Christian nationalism and more confident incorrect answers from Americans who embrace Christian nationalism. We theorize that, much like conservative Christians have been shown to incorrectly answer science questions that are “religiously contested,” Christian nationalism inclines Americans to affirm factually incorrect views about religion in American political history, likely through their exposure to certain disseminators of such misinformation, but also through their allegiance to a particular political-cultural narrative they wish to privilege.},\n langid = {english},\n keywords = {America,Christian nationalism,history,politics,religion},\n annotation = {\\_eprint: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/jssr.12760},\n file = {/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/5RRV4BMR/Perry et al. - Historical Fundamentalism Christian Nationalism a.pdf;/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/A77RVTT5/jssr.html;/Volumes/GoogleDrive/My Drive/Manuscripts/Zotero/storage/X8KKJZTS/jssr.html}\n}\n\n","author_short":["Perry, S. L.","Braunstein, R.","Gorski, P. S.","Grubbs, J. B."],"key":"perryHistoricalFundamentalismChristian2022","id":"perryHistoricalFundamentalismChristian2022","bibbaseid":"perry-braunstein-gorski-grubbs-historicalfundamentalismchristiannationalismandignoranceaboutreligioninamericanpoliticalhistory-2022","role":"author","urls":{},"keyword":["America","Christian nationalism","history","politics","religion"],"metadata":{"authorlinks":{}}},"bibtype":"article","biburl":"https://bibbase.org/f/fukRkkqBRPzYwN5Yq/Personal Publications.bib","dataSources":["5t6b8scZXg6RG4jPR","RXdTNm4remiboMTxT","5bQTjSTsaiufgPQhe","pfh3DfmWDzgTmM8Eb","Fkyj2w4eRjTqKyKbP","Dao3pBEzwezfvA6FN","GTXhqMhWGnbYWM3cx"],"keywords":["america","christian nationalism","history","politics","religion"],"search_terms":["historical","fundamentalism","christian","nationalism","ignorance","religion","american","political","history","perry","braunstein","gorski","grubbs"],"title":"Historical Fundamentalism? Christian Nationalism and Ignorance About Religion in American Political History","year":2022}