The distributive ignorance puzzle. Roelofsen, F. & Uegaki, W. In Truswell, R., Cummins, C., Heycock, C., Rabern, B., & Rohde, H., editors, Sinn und Bedeutung 21, pages 999-1016, 2018.
Paper abstract bibtex 7 downloads We observe that verbs like wonder do not just imply that their subject does not know the answer to the embedded question, but a stronger form of ignorance, which we call distributive ignorance. This is not predicted by existing work on the semantics of wonder, and we argue that it cannot be straightforwardly derived as a pragmatic inference either. We consider two possible semantic accounts, and conclude in favor of one on which the lexical semantics of wonder involves exhaustification w.r.t. structural alternatives as well as sub-domain alternatives of its complement.
@inproceedings{RoelofsenUegaki:16,
abstract = {We observe that verbs like wonder do not just imply that their subject does not know the answer to the embedded question, but a stronger form of ignorance, which we call distributive ignorance. This is not predicted by existing work on the semantics of wonder, and we argue that it cannot be straightforwardly derived as a pragmatic inference either. We consider two possible semantic accounts, and conclude in favor of one on which the lexical semantics of wonder involves exhaustification w.r.t. structural alternatives as well as sub-domain alternatives of its complement.},
author = {Roelofsen, Floris and Uegaki, Wataru},
booktitle = {Sinn und Bedeutung 21},
date-modified = {2021-08-17 00:00:00 +0000},
editor = {Truswell, Robert and Cummins, Chris and Heycock, Caroline and Rabern, Brian and Rohde, Hannah},
keywords = {inquisitive semantics,theoretical linguistics,ignorance,questions,modality,attitude predicates,exhaustivity,implicatures},
mendeley-tags = {inquisitive semantics,theoretical linguistics},
pages = {999-1016},
title = {{The distributive ignorance puzzle}},
url = {https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/sub/index.php/sub/article/view/180},
year = {2018},
Bdsk-Url-1 = {https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/sub/index.php/sub/article/view/180}}
Downloads: 7
{"_id":"ZzjMg9tMtXiam9QPR","bibbaseid":"roelofsen-uegaki-thedistributiveignorancepuzzle-2018","authorIDs":["2Cb7ifpWJWPabmTo5","2HhTQ9mTt7xrvcMQb","2SRK5PbshnXqqfwTw","2wG9qMMaDTwtQ8hQQ","3Rfu6PHFSmk77wS6k","3WhsHzoPZSNAkekJi","3cLXXoTzTSriL8K5N","3nswGXff7x6E2XrLF","3wzsoqsGTAat84vZP","3zhpAcB9qkPAPKPXe","4avyQNDHJbsimTLK3","4rTceDp8gy77sBdKm","5cYMd6BeuD3Abfyqh","5ccde963f0cf1ada0100029b","5d4f1cf66281deee010000dd","5de7bdb7bc280fdf010001d4","5de8ab5d3cfb74df01000057","5de8e1d1978afbdf01000055","5de8e97d978afbdf010000d4","5de8ea58978afbdf010000e5","5ded6dbc722536de010000eb","5def900945114dde010001a1","5df00e8ae128adde010000cd","5df202b2e4cb4ede01000054","5df2325c1e4fe9df010001af","5df523e6ea1457de0100011a","5df6a5f731a37ade010000cd","5df757a7182af9de01000180","5df7d7bbdc100cde01000098","5dfa1d7c1c2129de0100000f","5e00d483ea72ecdf0100002a","5e0271b62862b0de010000b0","5e0731d3513c7fdf01000012","5e0c5eea8d508bde01000365","5e0de57a45d2fdde01000015","5e0df04645d2fdde01000082","5e12756fa4cabfdf01000086","5e13919ca212e1de01000157","5e16c6a5dc7739de01000194","5e17a947d954d8df0100017e","5e1f8c4c08195af301000137","5e21dbc8af8ac1df0100017e","5e24ec9b0e3b0adf010000bb","5e253f93561b8fde0100009a","5e2b0cfedf8a5dde01000098","5e2c0a8a01c874de0100008d","5e2dfc61524f94de01000032","5e2ee5fa9033bede0100013f","5e2f25cd4557f3de0100019d","5e2fc2bbe075a2df01000065","5e30348946a666df01000123","5e3145058cf138de01000020","5e31de59bba4d0de01000131","5e32958de17accde01000019","5e34069cce4ca1de0100004f","5e3443950c807ede010000d3","5e35223c89e3d9de0100001e","5e3596efe5db93df01000048","5e35b1ae87b1e1de01000081","5e35d2d576dd53de01000096","5e36bb2c7b975dde01000093","5e380f5f918d4ede010001a5","5e38857e030bcadf01000025","5e39ae12ad94f9de01000158","5e3ac861f2a00cdf01000174","5e3bce70657d0bdf01000132","5e3c06b7ea028bde01000197","5e3c34f234cd37de0100015b","5e3d4ea5dc4cd0f3010000f1","5e3e29b4546544df0100004b","5e3f14f2e7f957de010000e9","5e3fd9c6e05cc0df01000085","5e40b18a019547df0100008e","5e42ade3e7bb7ede010000df","5e43dc039a621ade01000076","5e43e1779a621ade010000e0","5e448794ec14b3de0100008e","5e454c37a96575df010000d5","5e455b34a96575df010001c0","5e459a7523a133e80100003a","5e46fd75461d04f201000161","5e47d31baf70c7de0100004b","5e47eaac385298df0100002c","5e480e8cd4b913df0100007b","5e48aa08f1ed39de01000007","5e4998cd552c77df01000083","5e4a62c1cdaf71de01000170","5e4aab7d15f6c7df01000098","5e4ad0b10d7631de01000109","5e4ad4f10d7631de01000145","5e4bf5aa0dff2bde01000005","5e4c35edc1eb51df01000102","5e4d1b5b7d0ec8de010000df","5e4d699108a8e5de010000b0","5e4e81599b7bbade01000048","5e4f7b7b42a908de01000011","5e4fec60f5b214df0100002e","5e500d3d933046de01000073","5e50abc14e0862e4010000f5","5e50baede3d144df0100004c","5e519f462793ecde010000b8","5e53eb37d26e87df010000c5","5e540973e81566de010000fe","5e5447ad7a758fde0100014f","5e552e860096f9de010001b0","5e554e63e89e5fde01000021","5e56843ceb2916df0100004a","5e56d10c96127bde010001db","5e595ae3f5822adf010001af","5e5cd26daab7afde010000da","5e5ce7f6d12a0ade0100004e","5e5d226c168391de010000ac","5e5d59a5ad47bcde01000083","5e5e0cf65c89fadf010000c1","5e5e52475f9e7bee0100004c","5e5e744414f49fde010000b6","5e5e9d31c0a53dde0100024a","5e5f48c29771b7de01000130","5e5f7b285766d9df01000125","5e5f888f8d89c5de01000046","5e5fca066b32b0f201000116","5e5feabf5241b5de01000145","5e60051413e3aede010000d7","5e60dc6b839e59df0100004c","5e60ea5d839e59df01000120","5e60facf31c7d3de0100011f","5e6109a131c7d3de01000202","5e6134a397c182e9010000d7","5e61c6ecabaeaede010000f7","5e61f218e091e3de01000022","5e664767a77c4ade0100012d","5e665e9346e828de01000163","5e67493d4d24a6df01000130","5e678addd527f0de0100002c","5e69048b8457bade0100029f","5e6a014c8a1455de0100019c","5e6acb6dd15181f301000111","5gmKE6Sc9wPQRgegC","5o3HhyPr7tYXFbuRr","5wBnBZKiQPh29C7gm","5yqGycGro8KnjK4cC","5zw9gPsj4S8RNnN6B","68ywhqSuednuNpXtj","6AonTkeJKSXm9rxuj","6nNrRLTziEkswpJpX","6snLaBZe6gwqn3TSp","76ddQMq2tT4MTtDkc","7G5QXBrrrhTx5cqLt","7HKFB3raMQKkbiqc3","7KHD3fTQXSNExob74","7f9RBPvqhDdCR7tcj","7jKxYgCGyD7Js3rzr","7ppmrQCWo4bgQhRbt","7wTu97bQ9keaby3Ng","7yhtN8tGL9GjDvtuj","8BgJTjR5Z5v9yEWea","8JXixWBY3Q7v4YpsX","8Tw29Sg2xJYQksANn","8iThErxvtL35u9BLF","8nDvGbELMEiAMMyeZ","8v2hHBjWziEYHnQFs","8vWerB9oafkmwygM8","8w2k6d9gbcnM69wjy","94Sc83i6vikEGjTde","9N7JHz99xDHSStewp","9YmQCfJBYo8KN4HmB","A9bhs8xGHvis3RBhb","A9fQ3fe4ATt39XuF3","ATkRoM3R6Tu8Twtmu","AoLTHLSHv9MQpW4PH","BK26ohoMEgxqXiLPW","BiJCNwt7xPjx7E8ec","Bwjy9zxEh5d9dLmrm","ByeNGtzajx3TDCsuk","C2uPugfDg9XyndeCr","CGnQKXcgmPT8ZBKSo","CMedteGXZkNq8JQu8","CZbCdpJyKhB2ywAGS","DAjgMqQP7xzXMTHmX","DBYScMu55bzkKHeJ6","DkbLpDhYdiyekKTSJ","E2LyZrnfhYBEzgKrA","EFW8yjs4xRmodiJs8","EQy2rva6TEiuh6WEy","Ec8kLbpX4uL3qjodf","EkxpANyQ4fFrXXfya","FvHxysFxGWgjTXK99","G7No9QKfZmcbBZnDJ","GCT62EjEHsR4HMobC","GSh4WeXBLAz4ECYPk","GXjoZ6SYMniQYSDLD","GhGRJRgWd23uCkeuj","GwZMbQc39LQEYa6zy","HJKF4tdcuEgKovXL4","HKWqPzzZ5Nu4oJd8g","HcCkhKbXakTFyC3mg","J4bfPZTED8aH33vcE","J6RZtJd84p7qerGj4","JBFhmHGRQhf9WYsas","JEqRyTkmtHvkm7WSq","JJYfBCRrYxjdQTMzE","JebKg8yEv34HEYGQn","K8vKeMigpwdxSAq5P","KB4zPLomR4ynfn2gh","KBPJWdLKFA9xSQFdT","KMs7WDQLK3zBT35Fr","Khug5w34JGAjkuyst","KpRxcWxkp4YxrurAJ","Kzk3xRiQBKMTtrtj5","L2afbWaz7c7a45Kyi","LLBJWdaLo54gZStK2","LWWM5hoEmgosifsE4","LYtoTnRGdumBcFhDc","MQXoKQ6J8aiJEqCXx","MQep9nbWiJJrC9MEh","MfhX94sj9WTv8em7u","N9L6YHC49vT6mohXs","NE2KDKymx5EJqDAiH","NGg8McikbX4hqEk55","NJWu5BGFtYT4CHsLF","NP83StF2B4To7St69","P4t79ZbGaMG6B7rhB","P56CYJMupTZnQC7hB","PEgvjReY8kzFQ3tJi","PGWuHmXtjQNfMHb86","PLoFEycATFn32DNZq","PoYPN3XZ9eYonxtqp","Pt58Gq5a3Aw53ZsPb","QCG5SvJa6gPGD6QdD","QpHmpg4xeWZdMSd8L","Rs4P2TYmA299J6ojq","SG5Tgr7fifCMX3NLA","SXFfC4tFgmSS3WYdG","SaBApLLZ3pHXyCkRg","SgaD7G3s4R3S2c9NG","T8Q9pjXMzKBa2Wkqf","TBpAthCmmPK4YkjTL","TE58Lc4uKXLmXS6bw","TPwqnrAKKEJzAXFfp","TSJmdwkFWMSS5btfE","ToRpwcYhJ7uSkxdfv","TrNDuSetmwxiNKfSW","TvxChfLpCJSCZst8q","W37enW9LZkz6Jdchn","WAgxZuvo9v4BTrMQT","WFuPvmCei8sCFgjnZ","WY4GZNPJDgcmeLW7r","WiwqX4dpvyjQwXnc8","WmpDmefBeizNcmWgf","XCTnpw2Zv6cig7GHR","XRabXLD6e7qZDi9gp","Xi6D9gS6GgLvMR7CZ","XnbRewftP8MRPRgdQ","Y2rotKyHaRoKAL4Sv","Y899KeyGGe6pwYqAv","YETnNEHFhhB64mFro","Yfs9BrmNsibXkfQxT","YifD4oJtMuZN6ErqJ","YsPkiCs5sdPiRMTvc","Z3TRvQdSjHEb7LYjH","ZL3sWd85ntja5tTR2","ZqKc2i3CykA3bdF85","Zzb5CcD6ufnz7RcC2","a8kBJnLWmRTYttXyd","aAM3kn2ySycx265nD","aLqLnmzbeebEz22DE","aYTXkPZtt2dPRwREA","amMLfiayEgJSziNnK","arEEDyzGKadNLeMHa","b3cmESwFQDf4HNG3D","bCWcFyiC3dLd4uzBo","bPts2vnXEsd2zSoSt","bTsxPB7i4kus36oJd","bWqXCnz5LgJEmhBQJ","bxNuR5d5zTDLnvBoa","c3HDB23GhBKHDPukA","c53jnnytPKsxWi4jc","cnr5C2q85BHGc5RLe","cz3fgiXCSJJuyLNrG","d4RaCfx62ByChriMq","dFLo4aZ576uRdyiSH","dWpZqD22ayjnGv59S","dhxrYHJorKiAdYxRz","di8ydj7XXLMK2nhbk","djjbs4aAWRXfWu4n4","duDivp5iuExZgmJjY","dy69RZ6RYs7QFN6u2","e25DPqECrQLpBrMWi","e3zwFLQyRobjkZ6Cw","e4eMfLhpCo3nz2RLt","e5CgeWWQr55HRL2Hi","eZZrH53xkH5Ztqnux","edfXbKGtDjoEZRgva","ejDrMMe3Tgs6hoJM3","f6N3Qhsd4hPSJdSRC","fvk6bFPRy66cJG2qT","fxDDEgjGvxx6rw5SB","g8i4HPFiYZfsuaFiD","gBB9TvLL88pLi6YgC","gmKR493g4F6EJMYDF","h3CsJvs7qfkuQPP4s","h5kf2kCd3psm4MQzD","hQhRQ87QfbaDB9XkM","hRo57swZXmWp3rqeN","huxXrAXgDrkuJPtzL","i6oyHjkPgeh2PM2sD","iC4crPSm5NDWoqy3s","iG98KaNnyvBGQzecB","iJ4ZnEbMDBkX26urn","iKaw7kzYzdbfWq2pG","ih969QJZzS5EAWd7o","jLfSpqtGZN9qjPwFz","jSpGAFApqZXGryTig","jktgNegsHs8B2NNWr","jwtPQcsMAdB3HhqBJ","kDH6MwnCnMpkYcnRh","kErhoJ2yatjKrbfZE","kNjs5LBDSfNBwnhZL","kPrHRvjo3gC66L8mF","kYFK9nnd7yra4Eyy3","kb2weX5xr54LpF4vt","m6GWNhgj9dhGvEa4s","m6x2yzmkzwro5gTXN","mFhCwi7oMTLzz3E7W","mHWpZ2xDsFNAzTXxs","mPN3upM2GoNbTy2Ho","mYYs32PeD6EadRmL8","mkzaEecJLueLwJ54M","n4Z4mv9MhanHMyjGH","nSfjPuLnTqL3w27S9","nXYRuKatrPBwWnQsC","njBhR8A3yWAg9zk98","npxWNFpp9vCYBvr5u","nvKpgW7pavxmNdRHA","o8qhQxN2oBYupFFJH","oFYMcnjGguwAELXCN","omw5Dhm5kWutfiptY","oovnvgbBWnd4Pob6s","osdws7SR8RC4LjCui","p2jyLCJS4PEMx7jCi","p7cJkmbEcuFJzDNcw","pvaXAPvosoEhcyfcp","qLdcJFkn9cyLq8TYg","qNGxLoG6dzHHcf9r7","qPXoRJJM5B7A2Ti2Y","qR2drTgtGh7fnEbWk","qZj6bNiZj6M6DtGrp","qdYoMGc2wvyq6CTn9","qkgpHanJPkXb2T7J7","qmA4hwnKYYaS2JQMZ","qrbiqHEKJriyr8p6g","quqiSRBAggQB5jHoQ","rE3ciLZjbinZnT4Na","rG5SBWbLxTQKRc7Dd","rNiT2WrbmjdxrgqXZ","rYhKm56DRhutN3xPi","rfD9en76GLKxWfLhr","rsFyN7PoLZ2aRsspE","s85Xu54Y65iucsKvo","s9fgFYvkttzHHgMbD","sTEJXKk32Ee4apj4r","tE2qiBHm5NQEucYt6","teMr28uiyPJnoHoya","tpEfYHEzHMRoJ9chu","u3eBd7TnDqbdmX9Z9","udbsCGT7rraY7gxwm","ui3zhaSDSfAPi86uG","uzeLGvRAmvszchppf","vNLT68SZyy82Y99mZ","veE5KKsjwAusGBvgi","wE6kPmpcnnDbCpJeP","wQNbwLJqSRpz4n6QG","wZfPC2xdQgL76R7mq","wcR5X5kPqrfC2Qf8A","wuJpd63ABqqKF2tRA","wum4JCg9HMHsBiZE3","wxLgpMfcqcZhzJdot","xK6FqYcjQvG37Hqdy","xLfDYDWEh2iFa6vHe","yARxEfr2L9X4LMx6o","yDj89EDgnRSp9jBPW","yF4g26MTvcZQx7cqk","yLDqdarba4N3fsfdn","ywo4sKC5ypk4jy6Fz","zBw9G9zr8tNSE27Q5","zWumiSyWRxkTc4Lyz","zadzS5DG5dn3mgz8i","znjtgjSiBDs7Y5zFZ","zuWHLQExGzfA8nNKF"],"author_short":["Roelofsen, F.","Uegaki, W."],"bibdata":{"bibtype":"inproceedings","type":"inproceedings","abstract":"We observe that verbs like wonder do not just imply that their subject does not know the answer to the embedded question, but a stronger form of ignorance, which we call distributive ignorance. This is not predicted by existing work on the semantics of wonder, and we argue that it cannot be straightforwardly derived as a pragmatic inference either. We consider two possible semantic accounts, and conclude in favor of one on which the lexical semantics of wonder involves exhaustification w.r.t. structural alternatives as well as sub-domain alternatives of its complement.","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Roelofsen"],"firstnames":["Floris"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Uegaki"],"firstnames":["Wataru"],"suffixes":[]}],"booktitle":"Sinn und Bedeutung 21","date-modified":"2021-08-17 00:00:00 +0000","editor":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Truswell"],"firstnames":["Robert"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Cummins"],"firstnames":["Chris"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Heycock"],"firstnames":["Caroline"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Rabern"],"firstnames":["Brian"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Rohde"],"firstnames":["Hannah"],"suffixes":[]}],"keywords":"inquisitive semantics,theoretical linguistics,ignorance,questions,modality,attitude predicates,exhaustivity,implicatures","mendeley-tags":"inquisitive semantics,theoretical linguistics","pages":"999-1016","title":"The distributive ignorance puzzle","url":"https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/sub/index.php/sub/article/view/180","year":"2018","bdsk-url-1":"https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/sub/index.php/sub/article/view/180","bibtex":"@inproceedings{RoelofsenUegaki:16,\n\tabstract = {We observe that verbs like wonder do not just imply that their subject does not know the answer to the embedded question, but a stronger form of ignorance, which we call distributive ignorance. This is not predicted by existing work on the semantics of wonder, and we argue that it cannot be straightforwardly derived as a pragmatic inference either. We consider two possible semantic accounts, and conclude in favor of one on which the lexical semantics of wonder involves exhaustification w.r.t. structural alternatives as well as sub-domain alternatives of its complement.},\n\tauthor = {Roelofsen, Floris and Uegaki, Wataru},\n\tbooktitle = {Sinn und Bedeutung 21},\n\tdate-modified = {2021-08-17 00:00:00 +0000},\n\teditor = {Truswell, Robert and Cummins, Chris and Heycock, Caroline and Rabern, Brian and Rohde, Hannah},\n\tkeywords = {inquisitive semantics,theoretical linguistics,ignorance,questions,modality,attitude predicates,exhaustivity,implicatures},\n\tmendeley-tags = {inquisitive semantics,theoretical linguistics},\n\tpages = {999-1016},\n\ttitle = {{The distributive ignorance puzzle}},\n\turl = {https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/sub/index.php/sub/article/view/180},\n\tyear = {2018},\n\tBdsk-Url-1 = {https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/sub/index.php/sub/article/view/180}}\n\n","author_short":["Roelofsen, F.","Uegaki, W."],"editor_short":["Truswell, R.","Cummins, C.","Heycock, C.","Rabern, B.","Rohde, H."],"key":"RoelofsenUegaki:16","id":"RoelofsenUegaki:16","bibbaseid":"roelofsen-uegaki-thedistributiveignorancepuzzle-2018","role":"author","urls":{"Paper":"https://ojs.ub.uni-konstanz.de/sub/index.php/sub/article/view/180"},"keyword":["inquisitive semantics","theoretical linguistics","ignorance","questions","modality","attitude predicates","exhaustivity","implicatures"],"metadata":{"authorlinks":{"roelofsen, f":"https://www.florisroelofsen.com/"}},"downloads":7},"bibtype":"inproceedings","biburl":"https://projects.illc.uva.nl/inquisitivesemantics/assets/files/papers.bib","creationDate":"2019-05-08T13:00:03.839Z","downloads":7,"keywords":["inquisitive semantics","theoretical linguistics","ignorance","questions","modality","attitude predicates","exhaustivity","implicatures"],"search_terms":["distributive","ignorance","puzzle","roelofsen","uegaki"],"title":"The distributive ignorance puzzle","year":2018,"dataSources":["Fk3sHGcu8TSPuv2XS","E2KSoF3TSx2i7tP6x","Kr7zcZkBarYm3grc5","x2Aox4ZP7RsyuDjWX","LaLDs2mrYhQpgH6Lk","CEDzXuZSHaKCtJZEA","WRSofRd6uxxHywTGu"]}