Can Indicators Bridge the Gap between Science and Policy? An Exploration into the (Non)Use and (Non)Influence of Indicators in EU and UK Policy Making. Sébastien, L., Bauler, T., & Lehtonen, M. Nature and Culture, 9(3):316--343, October, 2014. doi abstract bibtex This article examines the various roles that indicators, as boundary objects, can play as a science-based evidence for policy processes. It presents two case studies from the EU-funded POINT project that analyzed the use and influence of two highly different types of indicators: composite indicators of sustainable development at the EU level and energy indicators in the UK. In both cases indicators failed as direct input to policy making, yet they generated various types of conceptual and political use and influence. The composite sustainable development indicators served as “framework indicators”, helping to advocate a specific vision of sustainable development, whereas the energy indicators produced various types of indirect influence, including through the process of indicator elaboration. Our case studies demonstrate the relatively limited importance of the characteristics and quality of indicators in determining the role of indicators, as compared with the crucial importance of “user factors” (characteristics of policy actors) and “policy factors” (policy context).
@article{sebastien_can_2014,
title = {Can {Indicators} {Bridge} the {Gap} between {Science} and {Policy}? {An} {Exploration} into the ({Non}){Use} and ({Non}){Influence} of {Indicators} in {EU} and {UK} {Policy} {Making}},
volume = {9},
shorttitle = {Can {Indicators} {Bridge} the {Gap} between {Science} and {Policy}?},
doi = {10.3167/nc.2014.090305},
abstract = {This article examines the various roles that indicators, as boundary objects, can play as a science-based evidence for policy processes. It presents two case studies from the EU-funded POINT project that analyzed the use and influence of two highly different types of indicators: composite indicators of sustainable development at the EU level and energy indicators in the UK. In both cases indicators failed as direct input to policy making, yet they generated various types of conceptual and political use and influence. The composite sustainable development indicators served as “framework indicators”, helping to advocate a specific vision of sustainable development, whereas the energy indicators produced various types of indirect influence, including through the process of indicator elaboration. Our case studies demonstrate the relatively limited importance of the characteristics and quality of indicators in determining the role of indicators, as compared with the crucial importance of “user factors” (characteristics of policy actors) and “policy factors” (policy context).},
number = {3},
journal = {Nature and Culture},
author = {Sébastien, Léa and Bauler, Tom and Lehtonen, Markku},
month = oct,
year = {2014},
keywords = {Boundary Objects, energy, evidence, Policy, Role of Knowledge, Sustainability},
pages = {316--343},
file = {N%26C_pre-print_2014.pdf:files/51106/N%26C_pre-print_2014.pdf:application/pdf;s5.pdf:files/51105/s5.pdf:application/pdf}
}
Downloads: 0
{"_id":"JZwwZfu7rjoC6xBSL","bibbaseid":"sbastien-bauler-lehtonen-canindicatorsbridgethegapbetweenscienceandpolicyanexplorationintothenonuseandnoninfluenceofindicatorsineuandukpolicymaking-2014","downloads":0,"creationDate":"2016-09-09T06:27:34.286Z","title":"Can Indicators Bridge the Gap between Science and Policy? An Exploration into the (Non)Use and (Non)Influence of Indicators in EU and UK Policy Making","author_short":["Sébastien, L.","Bauler, T.","Lehtonen, M."],"year":2014,"bibtype":"article","biburl":"https://www.sfu.ca/~howlett/howlett16.bib","bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","title":"Can Indicators Bridge the Gap between Science and Policy? An Exploration into the (Non)Use and (Non)Influence of Indicators in EU and UK Policy Making","volume":"9","shorttitle":"Can Indicators Bridge the Gap between Science and Policy?","doi":"10.3167/nc.2014.090305","abstract":"This article examines the various roles that indicators, as boundary objects, can play as a science-based evidence for policy processes. It presents two case studies from the EU-funded POINT project that analyzed the use and influence of two highly different types of indicators: composite indicators of sustainable development at the EU level and energy indicators in the UK. In both cases indicators failed as direct input to policy making, yet they generated various types of conceptual and political use and influence. The composite sustainable development indicators served as “framework indicators”, helping to advocate a specific vision of sustainable development, whereas the energy indicators produced various types of indirect influence, including through the process of indicator elaboration. Our case studies demonstrate the relatively limited importance of the characteristics and quality of indicators in determining the role of indicators, as compared with the crucial importance of “user factors” (characteristics of policy actors) and “policy factors” (policy context).","number":"3","journal":"Nature and Culture","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Sébastien"],"firstnames":["Léa"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Bauler"],"firstnames":["Tom"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Lehtonen"],"firstnames":["Markku"],"suffixes":[]}],"month":"October","year":"2014","keywords":"Boundary Objects, energy, evidence, Policy, Role of Knowledge, Sustainability","pages":"316--343","file":"N%26C_pre-print_2014.pdf:files/51106/N%26C_pre-print_2014.pdf:application/pdf;s5.pdf:files/51105/s5.pdf:application/pdf","bibtex":"@article{sebastien_can_2014,\n\ttitle = {Can {Indicators} {Bridge} the {Gap} between {Science} and {Policy}? {An} {Exploration} into the ({Non}){Use} and ({Non}){Influence} of {Indicators} in {EU} and {UK} {Policy} {Making}},\n\tvolume = {9},\n\tshorttitle = {Can {Indicators} {Bridge} the {Gap} between {Science} and {Policy}?},\n\tdoi = {10.3167/nc.2014.090305},\n\tabstract = {This article examines the various roles that indicators, as boundary objects, can play as a science-based evidence for policy processes. It presents two case studies from the EU-funded POINT project that analyzed the use and influence of two highly different types of indicators: composite indicators of sustainable development at the EU level and energy indicators in the UK. In both cases indicators failed as direct input to policy making, yet they generated various types of conceptual and political use and influence. The composite sustainable development indicators served as “framework indicators”, helping to advocate a specific vision of sustainable development, whereas the energy indicators produced various types of indirect influence, including through the process of indicator elaboration. Our case studies demonstrate the relatively limited importance of the characteristics and quality of indicators in determining the role of indicators, as compared with the crucial importance of “user factors” (characteristics of policy actors) and “policy factors” (policy context).},\n\tnumber = {3},\n\tjournal = {Nature and Culture},\n\tauthor = {Sébastien, Léa and Bauler, Tom and Lehtonen, Markku},\n\tmonth = oct,\n\tyear = {2014},\n\tkeywords = {Boundary Objects, energy, evidence, Policy, Role of Knowledge, Sustainability},\n\tpages = {316--343},\n\tfile = {N%26C_pre-print_2014.pdf:files/51106/N%26C_pre-print_2014.pdf:application/pdf;s5.pdf:files/51105/s5.pdf:application/pdf}\n}\n\n","author_short":["Sébastien, L.","Bauler, T.","Lehtonen, M."],"key":"sebastien_can_2014","id":"sebastien_can_2014","bibbaseid":"sbastien-bauler-lehtonen-canindicatorsbridgethegapbetweenscienceandpolicyanexplorationintothenonuseandnoninfluenceofindicatorsineuandukpolicymaking-2014","role":"author","urls":{},"keyword":["Boundary Objects","energy","evidence","Policy","Role of Knowledge","Sustainability"],"downloads":0},"search_terms":["indicators","bridge","gap","between","science","policy","exploration","non","use","non","influence","indicators","policy","making","sébastien","bauler","lehtonen"],"keywords":["boundary objects","energy","evidence","policy","role of knowledge","sustainability"],"authorIDs":[],"dataSources":["Bn7xRaKMY43f7hFwh"]}