Titi semantics: Context and meaning in Titi monkey call sequences. Schlenker, P., Chemla, E., Cäsar, C., Ryder, R., & Zuberbühler, K. Natural Language & Linguistic Theory, 35(1):271–298, Springer, 2017.
![Titi semantics: Context and meaning in Titi monkey call sequences [pdf]](https://bibbase.org/img/filetypes/pdf.svg "pdf")
Paper abstract bibtex 2 downloads
Paper abstract bibtex 2 downloads C'́asar et al. 2013 show that the structure of Titi monkey call sequences can, with just two call types (A and B), reflect information about predator type and predator location. Using the general methods of Schlenker et al. 2014, we ask what these facts show about the 'linguistic' structure of Titi calls. We first demonstrate that the simplest behavioral assumptions make it challenging to provide lexical specifications for A- and B-calls: B-calls rather clearly have the distribution of general alarm calls; but A-calls are also found in highly heterogeneous contexts (e.g. they are triggered by 'cat in the canopy' and 'raptor on the ground' situations). We discuss two possible solutions to the problem. One posits that entire sequences are endowed with meanings that are not compositionally derived from their individual parts (a related idea was proposed by Arnold and Zuberb'́uhler to analyze pyow-hack sequences in Putty-nosed monkeys). The second analysis combines a very simple compositional analysis with some more sophisticated assumptions about the environmental context in which the calls are used; specifically, we argue that the B-call is a general alarm call, that the A-call is used for serious non-ground threats, and that they are combined by the simplest (conjunctive) rule; but their interaction with the context conspires to make it possible for call sequences to reflect information about predator nature and predator location.
@article{schlenker2017titi,
abstract = {C\''asar et al. 2013 show that the structure of Titi monkey call sequences can, with just two call types (A and B), reflect information about predator type and predator location. Using the general methods of Schlenker et al. 2014, we ask what these facts show about the 'linguistic' structure of Titi calls. We first demonstrate that the simplest behavioral assumptions make it challenging to provide lexical specifications for A- and B-calls: B-calls rather clearly have the distribution of general alarm calls; but A-calls are also found in highly heterogeneous contexts (e.g. they are triggered by 'cat in the canopy' and 'raptor on the ground' situations). We discuss two possible solutions to the problem. One posits that entire sequences are endowed with meanings that are not compositionally derived from their individual parts (a related idea was proposed by Arnold and Zuberb\''uhler to analyze pyow-hack sequences in Putty-nosed monkeys). The second analysis combines a very simple compositional analysis with some more sophisticated assumptions about the environmental context in which the calls are used; specifically, we argue that the B-call is a general alarm call, that the A-call is used for serious non-ground threats, and that they are combined by the simplest (conjunctive) rule; but their interaction with the context conspires to make it possible for call sequences to reflect information about predator nature and predator location.},
author = {Schlenker, Philippe and Chemla, Emmanuel and C{\"a}sar, Cristiane and Ryder, Robin and Zuberb{\"u}hler, Klaus},
date-added = {2017-02-21 23:45:15 +0000},
date-modified = {2017-02-23 23:40:55 +0000},
journal = {Natural Language \& Linguistic Theory},
number = {1},
pages = {271--298},
publisher = {Springer},
title = {Titi semantics: Context and meaning in Titi monkey call sequences},
url = {http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/002411/current.pdf},
volume = {35},
year = {2017},
bdsk-url-1 = {http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/002411/current.pdf}}Downloads: 2
{"_id":"gEsX9u354rgEafkrf","bibbaseid":"schlenker-chemla-csar-ryder-zuberbhler-titisemanticscontextandmeaningintitimonkeycallsequences-2017","downloads":2,"creationDate":"2017-02-21T23:51:19.906Z","title":"Titi semantics: Context and meaning in Titi monkey call sequences","author_short":["Schlenker, P.","Chemla, E.","Cäsar, C.","Ryder, R.","Zuberbühler, K."],"year":2017,"bibtype":"article","biburl":"http://www.emmanuel.chemla.free.fr/Material/EmmanuelChemlaBibliography.bib","bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","abstract":"C'́asar et al. 2013 show that the structure of Titi monkey call sequences can, with just two call types (A and B), reflect information about predator type and predator location. Using the general methods of Schlenker et al. 2014, we ask what these facts show about the 'linguistic' structure of Titi calls. We first demonstrate that the simplest behavioral assumptions make it challenging to provide lexical specifications for A- and B-calls: B-calls rather clearly have the distribution of general alarm calls; but A-calls are also found in highly heterogeneous contexts (e.g. they are triggered by 'cat in the canopy' and 'raptor on the ground' situations). We discuss two possible solutions to the problem. One posits that entire sequences are endowed with meanings that are not compositionally derived from their individual parts (a related idea was proposed by Arnold and Zuberb'́uhler to analyze pyow-hack sequences in Putty-nosed monkeys). The second analysis combines a very simple compositional analysis with some more sophisticated assumptions about the environmental context in which the calls are used; specifically, we argue that the B-call is a general alarm call, that the A-call is used for serious non-ground threats, and that they are combined by the simplest (conjunctive) rule; but their interaction with the context conspires to make it possible for call sequences to reflect information about predator nature and predator location.","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Schlenker"],"firstnames":["Philippe"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Chemla"],"firstnames":["Emmanuel"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Cäsar"],"firstnames":["Cristiane"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Ryder"],"firstnames":["Robin"],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Zuberbühler"],"firstnames":["Klaus"],"suffixes":[]}],"date-added":"2017-02-21 23:45:15 +0000","date-modified":"2017-02-23 23:40:55 +0000","journal":"Natural Language & Linguistic Theory","number":"1","pages":"271–298","publisher":"Springer","title":"Titi semantics: Context and meaning in Titi monkey call sequences","url":"http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/002411/current.pdf","volume":"35","year":"2017","bdsk-url-1":"http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/002411/current.pdf","bibtex":"@article{schlenker2017titi,\n\tabstract = {C\\''asar et al. 2013 show that the structure of Titi monkey call sequences can, with just two call types (A and B), reflect information about predator type and predator location. Using the general methods of Schlenker et al. 2014, we ask what these facts show about the 'linguistic' structure of Titi calls. We first demonstrate that the simplest behavioral assumptions make it challenging to provide lexical specifications for A- and B-calls: B-calls rather clearly have the distribution of general alarm calls; but A-calls are also found in highly heterogeneous contexts (e.g. they are triggered by 'cat in the canopy' and 'raptor on the ground' situations). We discuss two possible solutions to the problem. One posits that entire sequences are endowed with meanings that are not compositionally derived from their individual parts (a related idea was proposed by Arnold and Zuberb\\''uhler to analyze pyow-hack sequences in Putty-nosed monkeys). The second analysis combines a very simple compositional analysis with some more sophisticated assumptions about the environmental context in which the calls are used; specifically, we argue that the B-call is a general alarm call, that the A-call is used for serious non-ground threats, and that they are combined by the simplest (conjunctive) rule; but their interaction with the context conspires to make it possible for call sequences to reflect information about predator nature and predator location.},\n\tauthor = {Schlenker, Philippe and Chemla, Emmanuel and C{\\\"a}sar, Cristiane and Ryder, Robin and Zuberb{\\\"u}hler, Klaus},\n\tdate-added = {2017-02-21 23:45:15 +0000},\n\tdate-modified = {2017-02-23 23:40:55 +0000},\n\tjournal = {Natural Language \\& Linguistic Theory},\n\tnumber = {1},\n\tpages = {271--298},\n\tpublisher = {Springer},\n\ttitle = {Titi semantics: Context and meaning in Titi monkey call sequences},\n\turl = {http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/002411/current.pdf},\n\tvolume = {35},\n\tyear = {2017},\n\tbdsk-url-1 = {http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/002411/current.pdf}}\n\n","author_short":["Schlenker, P.","Chemla, E.","Cäsar, C.","Ryder, R.","Zuberbühler, K."],"key":"schlenker2017titi","id":"schlenker2017titi","bibbaseid":"schlenker-chemla-csar-ryder-zuberbhler-titisemanticscontextandmeaningintitimonkeycallsequences-2017","role":"author","urls":{"Paper":"http://ling.auf.net/lingbuzz/002411/current.pdf"},"metadata":{"authorlinks":{"chemla, e":"http://www.emmanuel.chemla.free.fr/"}},"downloads":2,"html":""},"search_terms":["titi","semantics","context","meaning","titi","monkey","call","sequences","schlenker","chemla","cäsar","ryder","zuberbühler"],"keywords":[],"authorIDs":["3vam3cyWPNM6WQ8pq","4xkrsMSTKxWpnwkQ5","4zMxrxtuvMapq4g7N","52SKosH8pgCoCtR8W","548x4NQwTJJNM9J3n","58acc75648e5fc977400000e","5F8paHamMjqZPwuRz","5FaXD26NbrFa58Y3P","5de7627a179cbdde010000cb","5de7a8babc280fdf01000017","5de7c6565e1638de01000040","5de7cffb5e1638de01000147","5de80d549b61e8de010001d2","5de89d732c5eb2df01000112","5dea0796fac96fde010000e8","5dea314507a0c8df0100002a","5dea464e07a0c8df01000176","5deb6d759e04d1df01000074","5debb6999abf64df01000114","5ded75e6722536de01000172","5dee18de584fb4df010001a5","5dee2133584fb4df01000241","5dee3c4b0bde9edf010001e2","5def7b1445114dde01000056","5def9832706001de0100007b","5defcd1e090769df01000054","5df0004314db5cdf01000207","5df0d40d96fa76de010000ec","5df16363d177badf0100012f","5df21b751e4fe9df01000061","5df2b1e10f18f1df010000fa","5df32ef63b310cde0100018a","5df6fdd1df3bb9f20100010d","5df701dadf3bb9f20100014b","5df7860b5c8a36df010000b7","5df7d553dc100cde01000087","5dfa56fb7d1403df01000023","5dfb6ed1c2820bdf01000017","5dfb7d7dc2820bdf010000f0","5dfb88b7c2820bdf010001a8","5e063bfedc44f1df01000119","5e06cfa4a0810cde0100006c","5e0d940f675bf1de0100001b","5e0dfc2345d2fdde010000f7","5e0e4900d2eb5bdf010000d8","5e11dc703e1c29de0100002a","5e11e3f23e1c29de0100006f","5e13471c697554de01000012","5e1391cda212e1de0100015e","5e1452f2b8b351de0100010d","5e147a8908c265de01000006","5e15a52ee8bfcff2010000fb","5e15ae50e8bfcff2010001c7","5e175fe54df69dde010000f5","5e179dd0d954d8df010000ca","5e1a16ab9fbdddde01000019","5e1ba17d61cb16df01000026","5e1c6ab592587bde0100008e","5e1ccb870744c2de01000211","5e1ce8f7abed9bde0100019b","5e1efa5c147729df010000d2","5e1f7f5b08195af30100008b","5e202e5502c04cde010000f5","5e2088e280350bdf01000185","5e21a4893ef35cdf0100012e","5e22271071dcf8df010000b2","5e23141e7db53bde010000d8","5e254028561b8fde0100009f","5e25d971a6f19fde0100003b","5e261b4f408641df010000d0","5e27e8a668d625de0100010b","5e2abb1a8319d5de010000cf","5e2b1a64872e19de0100002b","5e2ea8bcb84405df0100008a","5e2ee0fd9033bede010000e0","5e2f30db78a7cedf0100006b","5e30b09cc99510de01000180","5e3103b2f59ac8df010000bb","5e31a2776be690de010000e3","5e32f592c1389bde01000124","5e334862e0067bde010000c8","5e3570724c2e37de01000004","5e35f8d55cd57fde0100011a","5e38b131645ed2de0100012b","5e38efa081a46ade01000149","5e3aada34518d5df01000125","5e3baf8f69c38bde0100010e","5e3c6e4967788ede0100010a","5e3cc4a7948886de010000c5","5e3d20b0c405ecde01000003","5e3ff0a5add5fbde01000090","5e412d65b54187de010001f0","5e414b97b7d170df01000169","5e41523ea59dc8df0100005e","5e415ceaa59dc8df01000148","5e415f68a59dc8df01000176","5e4162c8a59dc8df010001a3","5e416fe8d9f47bee0100009d","5e418288d9f47bee01000259","5e418dad8491fadf010000c9","5e41ee23a9454ade01000171","5e427592e4402ade010000c9","5e4276e4e4402ade010000de","5e42788de4402ade01000125","5e428130e4402ade010001a0","5e431854e27716de010000d1","5e43dabc9a621ade01000069","5e481110d4b913df01000095","5e48f8c9435326df010000ae","5e4aaa7215f6c7df01000088","5e4bba83733a18de01000167","5e4caf4c160d65de01000112","5e4d29457d0ec8de010001be","5e4e57d87aa348df01000155","5e4e597f7aa348df01000166","5e4e9dc264b624de01000048","5e4f417f8a3535f301000005","5e4fc8ed2c51e8de010000f8","5e53aa7037b729de01000035","5e54d62523abb4f2010000fb","5e554b7dca58a8df01000223","5e578076cef9b7de01000018","5e579d01041daade0100001c","5e579e72041daade01000030","5e57e754e391bbde010001c2","5e59052823e125de01000119","5e5924a6e60e02de01000009","5e5c065a82b694df01000073","5e5d22fe168391de010000be","5e5d5a8cad47bcde01000090","5e5d6a78ad47bcde01000180","5e5e2d071e54a8df01000311","5e5e5b8a5f9e7bee01000114","5e5f6f8c5766d9df0100005c","5e5f81bb5766d9df010001b3","5e5fa9fd19c3fade010000e6","5e5fd07f6b32b0f20100018e","5e60ef1c839e59df0100016d","5e61663a417d19de01000072","5e6263a111ac5fde01000050","5e62752811ac5fde01000215","5e62784911ac5fde0100024a","5e64028724d8f2df01000160","5e66619446e828de010001a4","5e668e2044d2c4de01000039","5e676bb01dcaf4de010001f9","5e6a759540f1fadf01000131","656dECH6vvyXHMezE","6E42b4D8TuTm6B4Dg","6Spq7cNwAEWMW9g6Q","6TgxkX2ZtXhpGdbsm","6vxcbu3BqH2sgqfaN","7FqtnmG2JNwuaBhky","7JHieuwQaC6CyGb9x","7LuS5jGkt6XSNCcpL","7yEQmpgb5ka9pkbCB","8H6TNJakufAdk23Yt","8XLfFCwc2YbysCfTH","9P7WNTNJJNYei3bNa","9REys6cTzYg94rEQb","9uHSEpgRiMqXXGAL8","A8bMxwHkRdxQepmYm","Ag63xdWKAbmSBiBmb","BDpcgBNQD23ovdTw6","BPx4ccE6EFzzdMaNL","BXjPEjLkLHrKhYqbL","CBwiBnbWrJEYncefL","CFLXxktiJz58DAB5B","CbZinGsuu6M9mEZiL","CdeS2NTSTTBKxrsHv","CtXkKR3RRyXkFXKJD","DN39Ja2YYFM3JPkL5","E5wkbHd7CtwmmkSfi","Ee6N5wZsZnkisfLjo","FGH3MeLszBPLR7BTo","FMbZWFQoYH3kJfxd9","FNvjGMBKaPCH82HxJ","FNy9vfpDaoq6qAgn2","FeR2WrGwm3yqvddS6","FqqmDSC6MfrMm267P","G7LYdnwRn9cgmooT9","GurQaKnmEQJk5ufFB","HTKbKfHHxC3eFDQaA","HYoq8qMrjqwzzpfJA","HfS2g6cip36Q8Xy7o","JarcZfSRcma2hqnuH","JihnZQ9QCWDQSSZXQ","JtgYLxG9f73ftqmkS","KpnLvyEZY7Tncj9bL","LYzuW2xandF6C2Nsf","LfmSCBH9DXpuoXzcy","LroXQvEnxWfnPc4Cs","McKyr25xpFBfPymE6","N3aidj5EFbi3hP3vK","N5EEMwYysmjvfzoTC","NvSm5EZaK8uSoWPJS","PXBHgKrBPyyH7MDR7","PjAwNugPZTLqtzAKv","QmXR8Wha4MZrstZjJ","QqQtW2BscQae2CMJ2","RfzXvfCCpiq6wfYKM","SH9prZsreY89gmGsX","Shw69BpSb2Kx993du","SmBPhy6tW2Hstu3EQ","W5xT6F97n4hsGy9tA","WyexaEPXMAsuioD79","XkmQZgJXKsNxjK9T4","Xqi8TRcxX5gfjGGSR","XuciHTMho7h3qdWDS","YKL5ADW6tgFiWjErp","YPhvpv5X9GTEAak4a","YrqhZu5djduTv49We","ZY95ABmLM9YsPHHKH","akWJmFLgXR3YZETth","c7XiqdBhsAjBhXBCm","cH8ycaRfQkzEdbESe","ctAgfMMqcyECdPCP6","dRqpN48xBRM3j6qPp","dejnsGxiMwzboF6t2","e7wYnouQPsMTZWB99","eXthjKb2ukYtBdPQp","fru7DJ9jmFM9QKmsX","fumc3TLDiGgYvhPmP","gJ24cLK5nX9ZXWKXF","gkDyLSfJJNRDKR7zz","grfE9yWkFE3FaeLDL","iHzS7P7ytXiK2XdKn","iJKCJyMrQ5fPpRMny","iKQoN43wMiMtnSDWs","j4mLvgStuCxZDY7Lj","jZJaToP554hWoePNK","kRzfbgDGRzSnBwLup","kZpshYtrc69zPxQ8z","kgfL98mjzDWGzXAP7","oADRfmzjLvooBNWwg","ouGchGJPTBJEYuBTb","oyFYHmqYGhABxQoLH","pEuGqQEQhP6PBjBQv","pciWJ7LfydTJ3jwNc","pxSShy9ZDj9RNtcGL","q32bouTeQiXYBCrub","qypEWBh6vJGrEPrcg","r7Jme7ov4StqfxrzQ","rb3Fr734tcAbBCTvq","rpFy7QQqiL32Ki2e4","s4CxYQZAcJzjehWnE","sxMZo9qnearXLNAnF","t3rEgyAwY28eRyQ8C","tJDEpD5kvyYBWCdJ4","tox9Fzriti3oa4jsY","tzRuiPzgbwubfYEcE","u2gtswbEAqWRugifN","ujbkMn2nvQTuxEPoc","urpnB9tnDB3SfyNbb","vHxYGQ5ACA3m95ADi","vWXp85FNyxFd3BPfF","w6BXxfgPQe2NcDSkA","wNkc9cxLEBz47Z8Fw","zWrRBQxp6ofKNusXt"],"dataSources":["tjiGpM3QkXrAR3DJb"]}