Aggregating courier deliveries. Steele, P., Henderson, S. G., & Shmoys, D. B. Naval Research Logistics, 65(3):187-202, 2018.
Paper abstract bibtex We consider the problem of efficiently scheduling deliveries by an uncapacitated courier from a central location under online arrivals. We consider both adversary-controlled and Poisson arrival processes. In the adversarial setting we provide a randomized $\paren{3 β Δ / 2 δ - 1 }$-competitive algorithm, where $β$ is the approximation ratio of the Traveling Salesman Problem, $δ$ is the minimum distance between the central location and any customer, and $Δ$ is the length of the optimal Traveling Salesman tour over all customer locations and the central location. We provide instances showing that this analysis is tight. We also prove a $1 + 0.271 Δ / δ$ lower-bound on the competitive ratio of any algorithm in this setting. In the Poisson setting, we relax our assumption of deterministic travel times by assuming that travel times are distributed with a mean equal to the excursion length. We prove that optimal policies in this setting follow a threshold structure and describe this structure. For the half-line metric space we bound the performance of the randomized algorithm in the Poisson setting, and show through numerical experiments that the performance of the algorithm is often much better than this bound.
@article{stehenshm16,
abstract = { We consider the problem of efficiently scheduling deliveries by an
uncapacitated courier from a central location under online
arrivals. We consider both adversary-controlled and Poisson arrival
processes. In the adversarial setting we provide a randomized
$\paren{3 \beta \Delta / 2 \delta - 1 }$-competitive algorithm,
where $\beta$ is the approximation ratio of the Traveling Salesman
Problem, $\delta$ is the minimum distance between the central
location and any customer, and $\Delta$ is the length of the optimal
Traveling Salesman tour over all customer locations and the central
location. We provide instances showing that this analysis is
tight. We also prove a $1 + 0.271 \Delta / \delta$ lower-bound on
the competitive ratio of any algorithm in this setting. In the
Poisson setting, we relax our assumption of deterministic travel
times by assuming that travel times are distributed with a mean
equal to the excursion length. We prove that optimal policies in
this setting follow a threshold structure and describe this
structure. For the half-line metric space we bound the performance
of the randomized algorithm in the Poisson setting, and show through
numerical experiments that the performance of the algorithm is often
much better than this bound. },
author = {Patrick Steele and Shane G. Henderson and David B. Shmoys},
date-added = {2016-03-17 17:07:15 +0000},
date-modified = {2018-09-07 02:21:35 +0000},
journal = {Naval Research Logistics},
number = {3},
pages = {187-202},
title = {Aggregating courier deliveries},
url_paper = {https://rdcu.be/4Cfy},
volume = {65},
year = {2018}}
Downloads: 0
{"_id":"aRPGmFZ4i8ABKMe6G","bibbaseid":"steele-henderson-shmoys-aggregatingcourierdeliveries-2018","downloads":0,"creationDate":"2018-06-28T12:44:25.167Z","title":"Aggregating courier deliveries","author_short":["Steele, P.","Henderson, S. G.","Shmoys, D. B."],"year":2018,"bibtype":"article","biburl":"https://people.orie.cornell.edu/shane/ShanePubs.bib","bibdata":{"bibtype":"article","type":"article","abstract":"We consider the problem of efficiently scheduling deliveries by an uncapacitated courier from a central location under online arrivals. We consider both adversary-controlled and Poisson arrival processes. In the adversarial setting we provide a randomized $\\paren{3 β Δ / 2 δ - 1 }$-competitive algorithm, where $β$ is the approximation ratio of the Traveling Salesman Problem, $δ$ is the minimum distance between the central location and any customer, and $Δ$ is the length of the optimal Traveling Salesman tour over all customer locations and the central location. We provide instances showing that this analysis is tight. We also prove a $1 + 0.271 Δ / δ$ lower-bound on the competitive ratio of any algorithm in this setting. In the Poisson setting, we relax our assumption of deterministic travel times by assuming that travel times are distributed with a mean equal to the excursion length. We prove that optimal policies in this setting follow a threshold structure and describe this structure. For the half-line metric space we bound the performance of the randomized algorithm in the Poisson setting, and show through numerical experiments that the performance of the algorithm is often much better than this bound. ","author":[{"firstnames":["Patrick"],"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Steele"],"suffixes":[]},{"firstnames":["Shane","G."],"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Henderson"],"suffixes":[]},{"firstnames":["David","B."],"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Shmoys"],"suffixes":[]}],"date-added":"2016-03-17 17:07:15 +0000","date-modified":"2018-09-07 02:21:35 +0000","journal":"Naval Research Logistics","number":"3","pages":"187-202","title":"Aggregating courier deliveries","url_paper":"https://rdcu.be/4Cfy","volume":"65","year":"2018","bibtex":"@article{stehenshm16,\n\tabstract = { We consider the problem of efficiently scheduling deliveries by an\n uncapacitated courier from a central location under online\n arrivals. We consider both adversary-controlled and Poisson arrival\n processes. In the adversarial setting we provide a randomized\n $\\paren{3 \\beta \\Delta / 2 \\delta - 1 }$-competitive algorithm,\n where $\\beta$ is the approximation ratio of the Traveling Salesman\n Problem, $\\delta$ is the minimum distance between the central\n location and any customer, and $\\Delta$ is the length of the optimal\n Traveling Salesman tour over all customer locations and the central\n location. We provide instances showing that this analysis is\n tight. We also prove a $1 + 0.271 \\Delta / \\delta$ lower-bound on\n the competitive ratio of any algorithm in this setting. In the\n Poisson setting, we relax our assumption of deterministic travel\n times by assuming that travel times are distributed with a mean\n equal to the excursion length. We prove that optimal policies in\n this setting follow a threshold structure and describe this\n structure. For the half-line metric space we bound the performance\n of the randomized algorithm in the Poisson setting, and show through\n numerical experiments that the performance of the algorithm is often\n much better than this bound. },\n\tauthor = {Patrick Steele and Shane G. Henderson and David B. Shmoys},\n\tdate-added = {2016-03-17 17:07:15 +0000},\n\tdate-modified = {2018-09-07 02:21:35 +0000},\n\tjournal = {Naval Research Logistics},\n\tnumber = {3},\n\tpages = {187-202},\n\ttitle = {Aggregating courier deliveries},\n\turl_paper = {https://rdcu.be/4Cfy},\n\tvolume = {65},\n\tyear = {2018}}\n\n","author_short":["Steele, P.","Henderson, S. G.","Shmoys, D. B."],"key":"stehenshm16","id":"stehenshm16","bibbaseid":"steele-henderson-shmoys-aggregatingcourierdeliveries-2018","role":"author","urls":{" paper":"https://rdcu.be/4Cfy"},"metadata":{"authorlinks":{"henderson, s":"https://people.orie.cornell.edu/shane/"}},"downloads":0},"search_terms":["aggregating","courier","deliveries","steele","henderson","shmoys"],"keywords":[],"authorIDs":["26gYvdajdPXPJE7x9","2L38RWkDRcZ7pNrCP","2S28FaHcvRe82HALu","2pim5rDqZtSdo8kRL","36vBNrAKQ6ZdJEe2Y","38s23udQojQibpA47","3EcfFsBN3R7JvEDRR","4jsvAjiatq5t2WPmq","569289aeec54c0f347000121","5FnGFhTQX8Nqf69Q4","5XfXT7CCH2CdbGTSi","5ZzCj7tQGxpgMuCrv","5de6d8d7abd988de0100011f","5de7df655e1638de0100030f","5de8ab873cfb74df01000059","5de8b31f3cfb74df010000cc","5de8d64b9e80cdde010001c8","5de8e6b2978afbdf010000a9","5de9d90f5e5ac8de01000168","5dea6e444f43c9de010000bb","5dec3180d39dc7de01000077","5dec3e3bd39dc7de010000fc","5dec9b5893ac84df0100001d","5def306ae83f7dde010000c3","5defa21d706001de01000114","5defac28706001de010001cd","5defc6b1d6a2dcde01000266","5df0d46796fa76de010000f2","5df14b68630a9ee0010001b8","5df21728e4cb4ede01000173","5df26d8f27cd2fde01000026","5df60db92b34d0de01000012","5df68a7d72bbd4df01000092","5df6c36bf9318fdf0100010b","5df7f538b9bb17df010000bf","5df896d110b1d1de01000042","5df94503ccc001de010000af","5dfa00842e791dde01000001","5dfaa028669fc3df0100011f","5dfea6522331dfdf0100004b","5e000c759292b5de01000008","5e031b17f2d70dde010000d5","5e0461336ef264df0100005d","5e05486e1965a8de010000d0","5e061c888e1565f201000063","5e07ea8ef1089ddf01000086","5e086de7ffbbabdf01000047","5e08b6697dc1dcdf010000c8","5e090cba79e131f3010000ea","5e095acc72022bde0100009b","5e0bfcf7e0da25de0100007e","5e0c51a3abd50cdf01000084","5e0c68f28d508bde010004f0","5e0db73bc7ca67df01000070","5e0e082ae2dbbedf0100006a","5e0ef46b5500a7e0010000ad","5e110755d6a01ede0100006d","5e1179e67da100de01000153","5e11980d91bc7ade010000d8","5e11ebb93e1c29de010000b0","5e123faac196d3de01000101","5e136663f16095df01000094","5e154e21edfb1ede0100011f","5e17839ecf35a4de0100014c","5e1bac6261cb16df01000080","5e1c006bbadffbde0100008b","5e1cc7ff0744c2de010001d9","5e1cebbeabed9bde010001ba","5e1d36df6b18c4df0100009f","5e1d928c3a6d8cde010001de","5e1e08aa2cced5de0100025d","5e1e30d4407a20de010000f9","5e1e6aaece9ed9de0100009b","5e1ea72ebedb58de010000c3","5e1fc88b2b05b2de010000d0","5e20de47b46c27ee0100014e","5e2399c8ed52aedf0100009b","5e28c8316acacbdf010001a3","5e28d0f6a3df5bdf0100003e","5e28f7f641639df30100005e","5e2d13616b217bdf0100009b","5e2d9f5c481fd6de0100008d","5e2dfea9524f94de01000041","5e2f694c0c34b9f20100007f","5e2f90ad48b7a4df01000149","5e31377d5a3ceade010000cf","5e31f8497c8d24df010000c5","5e333e71e0067bde01000011","5e3389e17a676dee01000134","5e35ea7d5cd57fde01000067","5e39930ed14579de01000204","5e3cca90948886de010000fe","5e3d52cadc4cd0f30100012b","5e404f26668183de01000123","5e41855cd9f47bee010002a3","5e420d0cebe241de01000157","5e422cec70cecede01000180","5e423354ac099bde01000037","5e424120ac099bde010000d7","5e43badf44c4f9df0100003b","5e4423effdc393de010001f2","5e4451e7df3c2af3010000f1","5e44be577759a7df0100006e","5e49b478cb98e8de01000091","5e4aa2afb70966df01000296","5e4b63e4cf8e89df01000096","5e4be9588f0677df010000ed","5e4cb94a160d65de01000182","5e4e5f347aa348df010001d9","5e4f1191e5389bde0100007b","5e4f3af9aa67a8de010000f8","5e5124c6fe63cfde01000034","5e51f9988240c0df0100008a","5e5322a512ed54df01000052","5e548ccafd5b13df01000038","5e54953dfd5b13df01000090","5e54b74e929495df01000102","5e555c86e89e5fde010000eb","5e55cff08061d1de010000b0","5e592a2ee60e02de01000059","5e5be9f8d49321e00100003e","5e5d776c0b73f6de010000c8","5e5ea2ce2fd1fade01000005","5e5eeaa3cc2eefde010000a5","5e6051b64a1c7edf01000064","5e606b639119f0de01000048","5e62c494cb259cde01000102","5e65403e0c7028de01000036","5e657ec86e5f4cf3010000d5","5e65cc3f14abd4de01000021","5e66600c46e828de01000176","5e69549caf718af2010002b3","5e6960a7af718af201000734","5e699a5020d4e9de010003f1","5e69e4013aab3cdf01000161","5e69ed893aab3cdf0100025e","5e6aabf3f216f6de01000138","5h4sgGHdCH72vAZaM","5ogF2CXCHfy6f484d","679Lm4jHWxqDJ8TiQ","6DyHskuuDXDGAzxHc","6nxwuyYbC6RW6ctek","6xnaCE8mZhgGBwoWi","6yshnZNE7WuhXH3zH","7Z5DLqPvh2BSihDYW","7cLQ9ngEAmrJ8o7ng","855LJ9b6fiWcscwFN","8Bsp47GekpgnCPQm4","8LpJRKsPW6YmLjZJ9","8eBEDfxsYFTcr6D8t","8iYgnty9yNpPx8ww7","8mvfqLAJDTcR47GXK","93H6SkR5ZZFczSQtF","9K4PKpyNwMnu6auGZ","9Qa7okxpMsCqu8Evw","9mnDgN4uqrz56E7FJ","9r3r2fPaAJWs3wXTg","AHQynee39fDWtZgBp","AWRZiPM7bCygBnXyG","AWxK6srKr36K857wh","AjYpJy8GHz5zJsf4H","Ausug2EGy92q96QPz","AxPH3xkMhKWuSpuyE","BHRCwsQXFpwDGc7fp","BbCWAbwCksowiDgHx","Ci5qw2GnxzxcJKDKo","CzzsKfT9JDCHEGYro","DQpuYXoY9deoFBaTM","EcHzQ49GGQ5vDZNLD","Ef3oocL9JKQdn9Pqq","EoAdiTpWDQfvqNMzE","F7ZzX5AsxaZoSgMFe","FFJ9Ae9pqtG42WKB6","FMkfumjCrWrrKQczE","FncA2ugmrk7yCPcZa","G2jFvsGAsqtaAovYM","G4EPY8koyPYHu6css","G5ugWiyiNQhicyqLP","GBNP6u82dyKn7rRkb","GXNi3uL7npAJxPkGQ","GpLkACYbcdZQ4LwdL","HYZqQAsEvasCppbuQ","HcP5Y9NFYc8Yojerg","HmP6LEgH9pKWqqPTy","HxwuuTuGWzf92icM4","JQuMGxgwzdR7sgxer","KAC5CGdzyQP4Wkc3D","Kk5EXnqpC5Cz65qCC","KsGc3CYAdcxGs8gNr","Ksk7KbxxhY3Ns7TRi","LJtGuaMSm2sCckWtw","LczSiSueKtaPM7AE3","MQrjHaLK4jomDMbeQ","McRaN26eWz4pvucZr","MdAPEtvyZWwXGfraS","NRRzjdv4ndHYvfofz","NiQpvaq38Pyuxo7sy","NkGZ2B3Rbj6g2MGwq","NqzqFFoKxN6tYyk8w","P7YN63ELLz4NXJotE","PFN4Ei227rh2Qxg9m","PXHrDY3LzsWyjkfH4","PeQ4rmLD8wLeNY39b","PfeDfM2K83tid3rA3","PhxXW7otyx9WwjSKa","PuZ8iZc94SYeu4GXv","QSavEd56isEzWSaGw","QnxXSMc5dBy77wZrs","QrdwRk3KXpNtadmeu","Rzrm76FFjE8xtscXR","S7XiMg9rfWuwddJMk","SEuAab2YuQaZp9Kde","SJ3PFN9RrLd2xi73p","T5TEj4TjxX3m6Z9za","TWcF2afrECWeXE4zJ","Tid6mW8cSXEe6RhWC","TsgA3oJKfMznyrR3f","WBRZyawcRu8gHXhrb","WWw2gZPyC8uLobjBS","WkhJ2E4yWrEJZq4Bk","XZL2CrSt6cfr4AbTe","Xb5P5zQGyqXyETFcT","Xhz6teaHpeim5fgkz","Xs8K9NawGq7viWdx7","XxBEsxiJpvDSkHwXQ","YMgHnMefgLiJEcTE3","Yvc8TZP5uBbxkcoXx","ZEBGCShPtkc7dR47b","ZFhDzqJSGaWx3tXZS","ZKadrEXFEkyief8xP","ZMn96y9dnoZpNNFHy","ZNF4tdDfuxBcjPNQr","ZRwZoRp5JnXD7nE7A","a5L6Bovd4stCePXii","a8QTuBQsxdGiPaTWP","aBN9ZrMni4AQYdfJm","aPFfQEZ9vKNkXy76M","aWWb9vq6XiTGKydz4","aYnk9v2xWPghMLGyu","b7hFe2YtzFbaPjg9A","bAnfMPpLJEKZZPePo","bBtfBJuvfws2WTJ4Y","bFsrsBuRb5nZhPfsE","dMZZR69yri54uFRhF","dSvGC6HzQgogDHy8f","ddpGacRuPforDhNzP","dkycrSPuYCmYHGiyY","dpBkCSXvuqRsjmAvP","duuQg8k8ZdwwRrgHA","e4QDjo2cojpWbA2FB","eMZdNEpEwzHdJyiT9","eWhngvkkPZeEGDsNs","eiJ7CHbyR2bYkPABw","fJuitccD2ezptNyo4","fLZeo3fwtsLxbaCzY","fPL8orbGXeaqeC2jv","fTs69k9HD9EDA6n4t","fYKiLZc9uogemS8mR","gRZLEHEL3bZsH9zB4","gv4yfeAf5ETLsNJ3o","h5FuGphsRDoZ3ntjR","hYEDsPLfrnPSFD8ba","hmjQRFMMGibFRfywb","hvWJGBtXa7LprQrss","ikdxjgfSujMGaEeuK","jAR4mi7YHYiRob65L","jEy68rHQFAh3369Dq","jXvs75SNQbHk8n26n","jz2BcEwfjC54yRWKT","k9ToFTaCqpCuRZfiK","kGf4ver4WvHM7Henm","kJ8zAHjdfnS9evg8e","kQLgRGZtRtbCu5CWQ","kksLvcknF9XCph3o8","kqNzuZW5QzyMC3NxQ","m5g4d2Ji5svFKfux2","mAqBMDgpdft8xosuS","mAvNfBKRHJs6Tf8GS","mCWMz9bshhBGganAv","mT35iKsRN84gooYso","md2cqfvKnwptM6x4D","mj5gvsoL3jHE7ycpF","n6fxq5nmkMGpbtrBn","nK52pNES5XKuHbk93","nLLdweZausMkCGJBb","neSCfH5uTpXEYx4PZ","nzsudJ3iaZqRkGKJA","o4QTNyHrFNm2Tn5rB","oB5DAkJusk5QrvMXc","oKQpecoAfcKZKdcp7","oM2vTjZAxRGBJJ5yh","oaqwoetYHNQcyyPSH","ojXkTd4kwMMYDGLky","ooYc6K5B8R87e7tuQ","oq9D4NZrqtGAG7pNE","pMSrJwNhffGiXw6LM","pPKZF868cEFjrHvG9","pezgZ2rz2DpBXKoxW","pjNJ9XaNuJq3enQf4","pmqK5QgF7tvFYCK7c","qB98657rKoQ2NN3o9","qCEAs5D2dXWTaXmsd","qfv8TS6NXKzQ2dP3e","qq5hdyFc5iEE48bfd","qw6N6haZvsNpg6JLs","rrYEng8q6EdhSGXL7","rwbaSRgkFWuJfAun2","s42rEXJehoarEyz43","sRLXGDDkQWrRJJJxP","suFwo2T3nx8T8XC3z","tKwA9xoRXgMDvf2ga","tSqtNKBiZes7dnSGC","tpLYe4KxGtnSxemcF","uFB9zrWpuJcP5Rs6W","uHoncFSXgEFtykauH","ukX5cWtSNPoY4kapW","vGMGbRbSQgtAb528R","vYauPKschnTPzPTTS","wDimZdXeX2Zg8Y7Mg","wHWQ8xBQeaszmm7jJ","wXEQe57PS5wMwDeCA","wi4AvGDtqgJANYiyT","wkB4afQhPTsyctvpW","wnP349xGsoeknZpXk","xLBNmFpRSQzeXfmj5","xThWiQnYRhfLcCESh","yH8xrJTcnFSDbocHc","ybJ8CoH86jDtFXbrw","z6EnaMv3Ph9XbKHDA","zKBMW5DJAxBj3bokS","zmYD3Z7SyZwWnpv2c","zuXc5NysK9hRSYYcJ","zzkyM84igmCKJcDup"],"dataSources":["ZCuKDjctePZJeeaBw","SEqonpKnx4miWre2P"]}