@inproceedings{WinklerSPCKB17b,
  author    = {Winkler, D. and Sabou, M. and Petrovic, S. and Carneiro, G. and Kalinowski, M. and Biffl, S.},
  title     = {Investigating model quality assurance with a distributed and scalable review process},
  abstract  = {Models play an important role in Software and Systems Engineering processes. Reviews are well-established methods for model quality assurance that support early and efficient defect detection. However, traditional document-based review processes have limitations with respect to the number of experts, resources, and the document size that can be applied. In this paper, we introduce a distributed and scalable review process for model quality assurance to (a) improve defect detection effectiveness and (b) to increase review artifact coverage. Therefore, we introduce the novel concept of Expected Model Elements (EMEs) as a key concept for defect detection. EMEs can be used to drive the review process. We adapt a best-practice review process to distinguish (a) between the identification of EMEs in the reference document and (b) the use of EMEs to detect defects in the model. We design and evaluate the adapted review process with a crowdsourcing tool in a feasibility study. The study results show the feasibility of the adapted review process. Further, the study showed that inspectors using the adapted review process achieved results for defect detection effectiveness, which are comparable to the performance of inspectors using a traditional inspection process, and better defect detection efficiency Although the study shows promising results of the novel inspection process, future investigations should consider larger and more diverse review artifacts and the effect of the limited scope of artifact coverage for an individual inspector.},  
  booktitle = {CIbSE 2017 - XX Ibero-American Conference on Software Engineering},
  pages     = {141-154},
  note      = {<font color="red">Best Paper Candidate (invited for journal extension)!</font>},  
  year      = {2017},
  urlAuthor_version={http://www.inf.puc-rio.br/~kalinowski/publications/WinklerSPCKB17b.pdf},
}

{"_id":"ms4W427BvtyJk3JTB","bibbaseid":"winkler-sabou-petrovic-carneiro-kalinowski-biffl-investigatingmodelqualityassurancewithadistributedandscalablereviewprocess-2017","downloads":1,"creationDate":"2017-08-28T19:58:01.531Z","title":"Investigating model quality assurance with a distributed and scalable review process","author_short":["Winkler, D.","Sabou, M.","Petrovic, S.","Carneiro, G.","Kalinowski, M.","Biffl, S."],"year":2017,"bibtype":"inproceedings","biburl":"https://bibbase.org/f/2Gq6bNPQ845THHiMW/KalinowskiPapers.bib","bibdata":{"bibtype":"inproceedings","type":"inproceedings","author":[{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Winkler"],"firstnames":["D."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Sabou"],"firstnames":["M."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Petrovic"],"firstnames":["S."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Carneiro"],"firstnames":["G."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Kalinowski"],"firstnames":["M."],"suffixes":[]},{"propositions":[],"lastnames":["Biffl"],"firstnames":["S."],"suffixes":[]}],"title":"Investigating model quality assurance with a distributed and scalable review process","abstract":"Models play an important role in Software and Systems Engineering processes. Reviews are well-established methods for model quality assurance that support early and efficient defect detection. However, traditional document-based review processes have limitations with respect to the number of experts, resources, and the document size that can be applied. In this paper, we introduce a distributed and scalable review process for model quality assurance to (a) improve defect detection effectiveness and (b) to increase review artifact coverage. Therefore, we introduce the novel concept of Expected Model Elements (EMEs) as a key concept for defect detection. EMEs can be used to drive the review process. We adapt a best-practice review process to distinguish (a) between the identification of EMEs in the reference document and (b) the use of EMEs to detect defects in the model. We design and evaluate the adapted review process with a crowdsourcing tool in a feasibility study. The study results show the feasibility of the adapted review process. Further, the study showed that inspectors using the adapted review process achieved results for defect detection effectiveness, which are comparable to the performance of inspectors using a traditional inspection process, and better defect detection efficiency Although the study shows promising results of the novel inspection process, future investigations should consider larger and more diverse review artifacts and the effect of the limited scope of artifact coverage for an individual inspector.","booktitle":"CIbSE 2017 - XX Ibero-American Conference on Software Engineering","pages":"141-154","note":"<font color=\"red\">Best Paper Candidate (invited for journal extension)!</font>","year":"2017","urlauthor_version":"http://www.inf.puc-rio.br/~kalinowski/publications/WinklerSPCKB17b.pdf","bibtex":"@inproceedings{WinklerSPCKB17b,\r\n author = {Winkler, D. and Sabou, M. and Petrovic, S. and Carneiro, G. and Kalinowski, M. and Biffl, S.},\r\n title = {Investigating model quality assurance with a distributed and scalable review process},\r\n abstract = {Models play an important role in Software and Systems Engineering processes. Reviews are well-established methods for model quality assurance that support early and efficient defect detection. However, traditional document-based review processes have limitations with respect to the number of experts, resources, and the document size that can be applied. In this paper, we introduce a distributed and scalable review process for model quality assurance to (a) improve defect detection effectiveness and (b) to increase review artifact coverage. Therefore, we introduce the novel concept of Expected Model Elements (EMEs) as a key concept for defect detection. EMEs can be used to drive the review process. We adapt a best-practice review process to distinguish (a) between the identification of EMEs in the reference document and (b) the use of EMEs to detect defects in the model. We design and evaluate the adapted review process with a crowdsourcing tool in a feasibility study. The study results show the feasibility of the adapted review process. Further, the study showed that inspectors using the adapted review process achieved results for defect detection effectiveness, which are comparable to the performance of inspectors using a traditional inspection process, and better defect detection efficiency Although the study shows promising results of the novel inspection process, future investigations should consider larger and more diverse review artifacts and the effect of the limited scope of artifact coverage for an individual inspector.}, \r\n booktitle = {CIbSE 2017 - XX Ibero-American Conference on Software Engineering},\r\n pages = {141-154},\r\n note = {<font color=\"red\">Best Paper Candidate (invited for journal extension)!</font>}, \r\n year = {2017},\r\n urlAuthor_version={http://www.inf.puc-rio.br/~kalinowski/publications/WinklerSPCKB17b.pdf},\r\n}\r\n\r\n","author_short":["Winkler, D.","Sabou, M.","Petrovic, S.","Carneiro, G.","Kalinowski, M.","Biffl, S."],"key":"WinklerSPCKB17b","id":"WinklerSPCKB17b","bibbaseid":"winkler-sabou-petrovic-carneiro-kalinowski-biffl-investigatingmodelqualityassurancewithadistributedandscalablereviewprocess-2017","role":"author","urls":{"Author version":"http://www.inf.puc-rio.br/~kalinowski/publications/WinklerSPCKB17b.pdf"},"metadata":{"authorlinks":{"kalinowski, m":"https://www-di.inf.puc-rio.br/~kalinowski/publications.html"}},"downloads":1,"html":""},"search_terms":["investigating","model","quality","assurance","distributed","scalable","review","process","winkler","sabou","petrovic","carneiro","kalinowski","biffl"],"keywords":[],"authorIDs":["2B3zZtfuH9AmxpWuo","2QsG9mfJnwX6MTuoJ","2jrFxieEqzijPmHCy","49dv4suCFf46nEFSX","59a4710e2e4566ba6f00002f","5A6un3HSxZaPDiXPA","5BTmBrmMozf6YgG5J","5Xaa4eConBa76EZjB","5de815459b61e8de01000279","5dedbd05e47c43de01000074","5df2323f1e4fe9df010001ab","5df8262ddc1981de0100002b","5dfc0a4fb371afde010000ae","5e00d4f7ea72ecdf01000031","5e177d32cf35a4de010000b2","5e1c542be556c6de010000e5","5e24c7d1981ceddf01000056","5e273928557b88de0100018d","5e29e136888177df01000188","5e29e9bd8fb0e6de01000033","5e29ed5f8fb0e6de01000066","5e29edf08fb0e6de01000076","5e2f5ae926e5cadf0100022e","5e3731a0646a98de010001e3","5e3e9fdc8fc127df01000078","5e45b6010920e8de01000031","5e4dffdbcc196bde01000144","5e57fed4a38020de0100012b","5e5ea112c0a53dde010002a9","5e5f20398ca867de0100007b","5e5feba85241b5de01000152","5e612a1f97c182e901000006","5e62e7723ba99bdf0100011b","5e681423c1fce0de010003f7","5e6829e0dfcfe3de010002d5","5e68ed471a389bdf010002fe","5e692ffd6964dedf01000037","5e6a42a0e3f54ade0100021d","6QPwdbn4oBshmv7s4","6dqbLtPtqmDfPtn76","7NssSDosapMwtTvug","7qizdca9gsw4HKauB","7rCPkhvup9LNQxuFs","9qNKNW92qhDZCwqc9","9zsfZu5qMELTmAhjx","AKLEQwiRMbTHnbbxP","B3j35ujgEN7NnDuao","BC6rKyeyBW4rnvBoD","BEXQaGSxnsXwH6ywH","BWc4GQhzJPEzBWCii","BWrEB42G2rZBhMXWP","BoieZoFeBMJdL7szA","C3QHjz3o9QHY2KM5z","CDoE7ubzqSgQDw4No","D9yfAL4Cz9raPXGYt","DMAfbTM8MTudubAmg","E3kQ5FnruEw9rpydE","EQmGWRtm5iTqAJr79","EjYMP7BmZWnnCe2G9","Fjz6zCPk6dhrQh7ak","GfRgLSdsCnJcxHqk5","H9jTFvgcfA2frDvhj","J68AKX8noZCCaTSTC","JX7K3iwdPuCFmXLSK","KY7XQ7o9dYKbPfNvZ","LAPXFimEzgfLvJ3x5","NXfXCuu5e8PLD9tjP","NcXBcwHjnnYsqtJwj","P3xQviDsAA5Nyepbh","Q5HhB8XwWxviNHds8","QNZis6ZZX7Yjbx8dE","Qc6N7XXPtrqPpoz4E","SX7EYSkFddyzaBm6X","TEfrhfD2aFrBZaPoC","TdDrDsjDeT5x75mSb","X52u8rd5YXy5LA7un","XJLfEnjtpExqCJZaW","XMNYKpR8WAFvirRqK","XihJbHkzXLgRtNyxn","XsXTSrDqyDoKDSmNq","YqBvGBJjQxyDSh7S5","YyAJT6vXC6BKreqDz","Zrx3awt824zfj7sSq","auNZr9WLsGE5yM95y","dFvjKbaZaDAq7ckZJ","dPKdaA8smJs9fD9aK","e3dB4oaTL7GMfFgxK","eNvtiALsMm2uYYycD","eyyzX9y5xtqzMnTRj","gz3th4fHvqAew9t4d","hXHpEcrrfJ2s2iYfG","hdQfGGPRY6SRzm5Ko","iMFD4aggCkDpRbjzY","iSDp642Wcpz8tx3Et","idw5XK3YYZ9zoiTRQ","jQSpXNQ9zGdK9MNg5","jnzKc2JyGfzCkYHhd","juFRAZ7Ght5WjDjmL","k3N5QRHDiN6riZiAM","kd57C3edL7i8Wd84N","mfAwYkjQak83CbSTc","nrZNNBXjpC2enCsS6","o8dowv3jmQXqEKvC2","oab566NG74uXsBmwv","pAEkuNSzoQMJv6HEA","pPPN4e9LKJdN8Mxxy","pRJmqmExQ3P4YnarG","pcdRpqFz4kQKG67b2","peFdo2JYEZeDcgz5y","pmHQ27YZJtYA8bWLb","qRaeFjmTD9bcnWRpS","qujKQpt7j7DMJJ7RH","rhwhwtMA472RbPiq4","sgMZQR6tjyrtQJMjs","th5Bb6GjMT6NDynxY","tkio9AppMC7RRAmn3","up5b9JPmGJAE7cKzM","wE7ePiMnAtpNHo5xB","wjubqSThzCzkZtY4R","wuZMB8CeGEzZRou5r","x98pJyoike8bxbRn6","xSybShZMHQMQ8yMSF","xerEPhmhSdZJXb6QX","yqEQy2HisnquBmuLK","yvRZvxhXXSADSSiod","z8Hfj7RHYQjKdxD2H","zGAYQbmvDTTNydwuA"],"dataSources":["JhEx5LqjNuowkDTYw","vp6ff9ZJkhXGDuh9E","FPdHx2YNMWt6KHbaS","oL8GbjE74fizfjkxY","Wbj3iHa4hGsGjEGJE","q7rgFjFgwoTSGkm3G","aKfxcyv7C9p9ytdpG","9pAzChfPy53GguqQk","B8Jierr7smZsGa7Jb","tvqztEQv84agmtPEB","FGDKYBjH9upApdKoL"]}